Abstract
BACKGROUND:
The medial hamstring (MH) and lateral hamstring (LH) can be selectively trained through tibial internal and external rotation during prone knee flexion. However, no study has identified how a combined tibial rotation and lumbo-pelvic stability strategy influences MH and LH muscle activities.
OBJECTIVE:
To investigate the combined effects of tibial rotation and the abdominal drawing-in maneuver (ADIM) on MH and LH muscle activities as well as pelvic rotation during prone knee flexion.
METHODS:
Fifteen female volunteers performed prone knee flexion with tibial internal and external rotation, with and without the ADIM. Under each condition, MH and LH muscle activities were measured by surface electromyography (EMG), and the pelvic rotation angle by a smartphone inclinometer application.
RESULTS:
The results showed increased MH (without the ADIM:
CONCLUSIONS:
These findings suggest that the ADIM could be useful for reducing compensatory pelvic rotation and enhancing selective muscle activation in the MH and LH, according to the direction of tibial rotation, during prone knee flexion.
Introduction
Medial hamstring (MH) and lateral hamstring (LH) activation imbalance is associated with medial knee osteoarthritis (OA) and anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury. Lynn and Costigan reported a decreased MH and LH hamstring activation ratio during walking in those with medial knee OA, which was a compensation strategy to overcome the increased knee varus moment [1]. Briem et al. demonstrated greater relative LH hamstring activation in an ACL injury group compared to a control group due to increased knee valgus, as an element of the ACL injury mechanism [2]. Thus, an effective strategy to enhance selective activation of the hamstring muscle is crucial to prevent and/or treat knee injuries.
Changing the position of the tibia can help to selectively activate the MH or LH muscles. Lynn and Costigan demonstrated that the MH/LH activation ratio significantly increases upon tibial internal rotation and decreases upon tibial external rotation during standard lower limb exercises [3]. Mohamed et al. reported that the maximum MH and LH muscle activities significantly increased upon the tibial internal and external rotations, respectively, during 70
Hamstring muscle activities are affected by tibial rotation and lumbo-pelvic stability. Oh et al. demonstrated that a lumbo-pelvic stabilization strategy using the abdominal drawing-in maneuver (ADIM) increases hamstring activity during prone hip extension [5]. Park et al. also showed an increase in hamstring muscle activity under the ADIM condition compared with the non-ADIM condition during prone knee flexion in patients with chronic low back pain [6]. In addition, they observed significantly reduced pelvic rotation under the ADIM condition, suggesting that a lumbo-pelvic stabilization strategy using the ADIM could lead to increased hamstring muscle activation in the neutral pelvic position [6].
These findings indicate that hamstring muscle activity changes significantly according to the direction of tibial rotation and the lumbo-pelvic stabilization strategy. Although tibial rotation and lumbo-pelvic stabilization strategies are effective for increasing hamstring muscle activation when used separately, no study has investigated how the combination of these strategies influences hamstring muscle activation and pelvic rotation. Therefore, this study analyzed the combined effect of tibial rotation and ADIM on electromyography (EMG) activity in the MH and LH as well as pelvic rotation, during prone knee flexion. We hypothesized that ADIM would facilitate EMG activity of the MH and LH, and reduce pelvic rotation. Meanwhile, internal and external tibial rotation would increase MH and LH muscle activity, respectively, during prone knee flexion. Given the clinical significance of the hamstring muscles, exercise methods that can selectively enhance MH and LH activities will be useful options for clinicians planning hamstring strengthening exercise strategies.
Methods
Participants
Fifteen healthy female volunteers who could perform activities of daily living without pain participated in this study (age
Prone knee flexion with tibial rotation under the non-ADIM (A) and ADIM (B) conditions. Abbreviation: ADIM, abdominal drawing-in maneuver.
Surface EMG electrodes (Delsys Triagno Wireless EMG system; Delsys Inc., Boston, MA, USA) were placed on the participants’ muscles parallel to the muscle fiber direction. The skin was shaved and, cleaned, and two surface electrode pairs were placed on the semimembranosus/semitendinosus (MH) and biceps femoris (LH) muscles of the dominant leg [9]. The EMG signals were amplified and sampled at 2,000 Hz with a bandwidth of 20–450 Hz. The raw EMG data were analyzed based on the root mean square and a 125-ms interval. The MH electrodes were placed at the midpoint between the ischial tuberosity and medial femoral epicondyle. The LH electrodes were placed between the ischial tuberosity and lateral femoral epicondyle. The muscle bellies for electrode placement on the MH and LH were manually identified by palpation during submaximal contraction. For normalization, two trials of 5 s maximal voluntary isometric contraction (MVIC) of the knee flexor, using knee flexion with internal tibial rotation (for MH), or external tibial rotation (for LH), were performed. While in the prone position, the participants performed 30
Smartphone-based measurement tool (SBMT)
Pelvic rotation in both the sagittal and transverse planes has been reported as a common compensatory movement during prone knee flexion [6, 10, 11]. Although 3D motion analysis has been used to measure kinematics of the pelvis [6, 10, 11], a previous study demonstrated that pelvic transverse rotation can be reliably measured using a smartphone inclinometer application [12]. Similarly, in this study, we measured the pelvic transverse rotation angle using a smartphone inclinometer application. For pelvic transverse rotation measurements, smartphone was connected to the smartphone holder of SBMT, an instrument containing a wooden frame that could hold the smartphone in a position where it can measure the transverse rotation angle of the pelvis. A previous study demonstrated excellent reliability in pelvic rotation measurement using the SMBT [12]. To measure pelvic rotation, the bottom horizontal bar of the SBMT was placed on both posterior superior iliac spines. An Android inclinometer application (clinometer level and slope finder; Plaincode Software Solutions, Stephanskirchen, Germany) was used to record the pelvic rotation angle during prone knee flexion. Before the SMBT measurements, the inclinometer application was calibrated by placing the SBMT on a flat surface. The absolute pelvic rotation angle was measured during each prone knee flexion task.
Procedure
Before performing prone knee flexion tasks, the participants stretched their hamstrings to prevent muscle strain [13]. The participants tilted their pelvises forward with a straight-back posture while placing one leg on a chair in the standing position [14]. Each 20–30-s stretch, was repeated three times [15]. The participants were allowed rest periods of 45 s between stretches.
Prone knee flexion without the ADIM
The participants were asked to assume a prone position on the treatment table, then actively flex the knee joint toward the buttocks as much as possible for each of two tibial rotation conditions (e.g., internal and external) (Fig. 1A). Under both conditions, an investigator manually rotated the tibia to the direction of internal or external rotation until firm resistance was encountered. Subsequently, the participants flexed their knees for 5 s under each tibial rotation condition.
Muscle activities of the medial and lateral hamstring muscles and pelvic rotation angles during prone knee flexion
Muscle activities of the medial and lateral hamstring muscles and pelvic rotation angles during prone knee flexion
A pressure biofeedback unit was placed between the treatment table and the participant’s lower abdomen, while the participant was situated in a prone position. The pressure biofeedback unit was inflated to 70 mmHg, and the participant drew in their lower abdomen to reach pressure of 60 mmHg. The participant then performed prone knee flexion while maintaining a pressure of 60 mmHg during prone knee flexion with tibial internal or external rotation, as in knee flexion without the ADIM (Fig. 1B). Pressure changes of
Each prone knee flexion was repeated three times with a 1-min rest period between trials and a 5-min rest period between conditions. To minimize learning effects regarding the ADIM, prone knee flexion without the ADIM was performed first, followed by prone knee flexion with the ADIM. Tibial internal or external rotation was randomly applied in each prone knee flexion condition.
Statistical analyses
IBM SPSS Statistics (ver. 25.0; IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA) was used to analyze the MH and LH muscle activities and pelvic rotation angle. For analysis of EMG muscle activity across the exercise conditions, 2
Results
The results of statistical analysis are summarized in Table 1. An interaction between ADIM condition and tibial rotation was found for the MH (
Post hoc analysis showed that MH muscle activity (without ADIM:
When the ADIM was applied during knee flexion, greater muscle activities in both the MH (internal tibial rotation:
For the pelvic rotation angle, no significant interaction between the ADIM condition and tibial rotation (
Discussion
The present study demonstrated that ADIM led to greater EMG activity of MH and LH and lesser pelvic rotation while tibial internal and external rotations increased MH and LH muscle activities, respectively, during prone knee flexion. However, significant ADIM
These study findings indicated that tibial internal and external rotation enhanced MH and LH muscle activities. Our results are consistent with those of Fiebert et al., who demonstrated that MH muscle activity increased during knee flexion with tibial internal rotation, and that LH muscle activity increased under knee flexion with tibial external rotation, when participants resisted a force equivalent to 5% of their body weight [15]. Lynn and Costigan reported that altering the tibial position during lower limb exercise could help selectively activate the MH or LH [3]. They explained that the hamstring muscle is responsible for producing rotations in the transverse plane of the knee, which influences selective activation of the MH and LH according to the direction of tibial rotation. Anatomically, tibial internal and external rotation respectively causes the MH and LH muscle fiber directions to be closer to line of action of each muscle. Muscle contraction is presumably reinforced when the muscle-fiber direction is closer to line of muscle action [16]. Overall, our data support previous findings that tibial rotation can be an effective strategy for improving the selective activation of the MH and LH.
With the ADIM, MH and LH muscle activities increased significantly increased during prone knee flexion with tibial internal and external rotation, respectively. An important compensatory action during prone knee flexion is anterior pelvic tilt due to excessive erector spinae muscle activity [6]. Unwanted anterior pelvic tilt can be prevented by the contraction of hamstring muscles because these muscles produce posterior pelvic tilt due to their common origin at the ischial tuberosity. Therefore, application of the ADIM in the present study might have facilitated hamstring muscle activation to maintain a neutral pelvic position against the pelvic anterior tilt force caused by knee flexion, thereby producing greater hamstring muscle activity during the ADIM compared to the non-ADIM condition. Another possible explanation for the present results may involve the influence of proximal stability on distal limb function [17]. Stabilization of the trunk, pelvis, and hip is necessary for specific limb movements during various functional activities [17]. Earl and Hoch demonstrated that proximally focused (e.g., trunk and hip) strengthening exercises increased hip strength and reduced the knee adduction moment in women with patellofemoral pain syndrome [18]. Those findings imply that proximal stability influences lower extremity movement patterns and improves lower extremity function. Therefore, we presume that application of the ADIM improved lumbo-pelvic stability and led to enhanced hamstring muscle function, thereby increasing hamstring muscle activity during prone knee flexion in the present study.
The present study demonstrated a significant ADIM
In the present study, pelvic rotation was significantly reduced when lumbo-pelvic stabilization was applied using the ADIM (
There were several limitations in this study. First, participants were women. Notably, the range of tibial rotation differs between men and women [26]. Therefore, only women were included to avoid bias related to sex characteristics. However, to generalize our findings, further research recruiting more subjects, including males, will be needed. Second, this study did not investigate how tibial rotation ranges affected MH and LH muscle activities because participants performed maximum tibial internal and external rotation in this study. Considering that the previous study showed changes in hamstring muscle activity according to the degree of tibial rotation [27], measuring the tibial rotation angle may provide clinicians with detailed information on the hamstring activation pattern during prone knee flexion with the ADIM. Therefore, additional studies are needed to compare MH and LH muscle activities according to the degree of tibial rotation. Finally, although the ADIM was applied to improve lumbo-pelvic stability in this study, changes in trunk muscle activity that contributed to lumbo-pelvic stabilization were not measured during the ADIM.
Conclusions
Our findings showed that application of the ADIM led to greater EMG activity of the MH and LH, and reduced pelvic rotation, while internal and external tibial rotation increased MH and LH muscle activities, respectively, during prone knee flexion. These findings imply that a lumbo-pelvic stabilization strategy using the ADIM can reduce compensatory pelvic rotation and enhance selective activation of the MH and LH according to the direction of tibial rotation during prone knee flexion.
Footnotes
Conflict of interest
None declared.
