The experiments reported in the present paper were set up in order to restrict some of the syntactic and semantic criteria involved in the task of tonic identification. Experiment 2 examines tonic identification in a particular type of contrastive sentence and in cleft sentences. Experiments 3-5 examine the effect of the discourse on tonic identification. The results indicate that when the information focus is a contrasted element that contradicts a previous element, the information focus is identified consistently as tonic. When the information focus is a "new" element realized as the leftmost lexical item in a sentence, it is normally identified as the tonic, but if judges are asked to identify tonics in utterances that do not have a clear "given/new" structure, then several tonics are identified. The results indicate, therefore, that the tone group in its unmarked form will contain several peaks of prominence.