‘Normalizing Informality’ in Local–Transnational Spaces: Contraband,Conflict and Street Trade in Eastern Ethiopia

Abstract

Informality arguably remains the main source of employment and income for most participants in the cities of the Global South. It is rampant in cities along national borders and transport routes. This paper discusses the ‘normality of informality’, exploring the nexus between contraband, conflict and informal cross-border trade in a local–transnational space, drawing from Dire Dawa in eastern Ethiopia. Data were collected through key informants and in-depth interviews in 2015/2016 and 2019. This study also benefitted from secondary sources. Since its establishment in 1902, the city has become a major hub of commerce, industry, transportation, and cross-border trade. Combining the literature on the informal economy and cross-border trade and drawing on evidence from eastern Ethiopia, this study explores how trade is deeply embedded in local–transnational interactions through partnerships between state and non-state actors. This study argues that informal cross-border trade is a societal mode of provisioning with extensive livelihood opportunities that survive even through periods of conflict and repression. Thus, reducing the vulnerability of participants in informal cross-border trade could be a more effective policy target than eradicating them.

Keywords

Ethiopia informal cross-border trade street trade

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abdi

(2022) Fixing the price: the politics of the khat trade between Ethiopia and Somaliland. Research paper. Nakuru, Kenya: Rift Valley Institute.

Addisu

(2018) The effect of contraband on government revenue: case of Segen Area Peoples Zone. Global Journal of Management and Business Research: B Economics and Commerce 18(3): 1–15.

African Development Bank (AfDB) (2019) East Africa Economic Outlook 2019. Abidjan, Côte d’Ivoire: AfDB. Available at: https://www.afdb.org/fileadmin/uploads/afdb/Documents/Publications/2019AEO/REO_2019_-_East_Africa_.pdf (accessed May 2020).

Afrika

J-G

Ajumbo

(2012) Informal cross-border trade in Africa: implications and policy recommendations. Africa Economic Brief: Africa Development Bank. Available at: https://www.afdb.org/fileadmin/uploads/afdb/Documents/Publications/Economic%20Brief%20-%20Informal%20Cross%20Border%20Trade%20in%20Africa%20Implications%20and%20Policy%20Recommendations%20-%20Volume%203.pdf

Ali

(2013) Assessment of illegal (contraband) trade on the pastoral livelihood: case study of Miesso Woreda, Shinnile zone, Somali regional state. Unpublished MA Thesis in Management, Mekelle University, Mekele, Ethiopia.

Anadolu Agency (2019) Ethiopia jails 3 German firm workers for illegal trade, 24 April. Available at: https://www.aa.com.tr/en/africa/ethiopia-jails-3-german-firm-workers-for-illegal-trade/1461920 (accessed June 2022).

BBC (2020) Timeline: Ethiopia and Somalia. Available at: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/6159735.stm (accessed June 2022).

Belayneh

Moti

Abreha

, et al. (2015) Cross-border contraband trade across the main route from Moyale to Hawassa: an exploration into the causes and consequences. Journal of Administrative and Business Studies 7(2): 68–92.

Bereket

Israel

(2014) Dumping through street traders: impact on legit businesses may continue for the near future. Fortune, 28 December. Ethiopia: Dumping Through Street Vendors. Available at: allAfrica.com

10.

Bogale

Mosisa

Mesele

, et al. (2018) The nature of cross-border contraband trade across the main route of Moyale – Hawassa. Berhan International Research Journal of Science and Humanities 2(1): 22–38.

11.

Central Statistical Agency (CSA) (1999) The 1999 National Labour Force Survey. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: CSA.

12.

Central Statistical Agency (CSA) (2013) Population Projections for Ethiopia 2007–2037. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: CSA, Addis Ababa.

13.

Central Statistical Agency (CSA) (2014) Statistical Report on the 2013 National Labour Force Survey. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: Statistical Bulletin.

14.

Central Statistical Agency (CSA) (2018) Statistical Report on The 2018 Urban Employment Unemployment Survey. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: Statistical Bulletin 586.

15.

Chiliya

Masocha

Zindiye

(2012) Challenges facing Zimbabwean cross border traders trading in South Africa: a review of literature. Chinese Business Review 11(6): 564–570.

16.

Daimon

(2010) Smuggling through fluid and porous African Borderlands and the state’s response: the case of the Zimbabwe-South Africa border. In: ABORNE conference on cross-border trade in Africa: the local politics of a global economy, Basel. Available at: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5a44f918f9a61e04cdd5d717/t/5e8c8d395f00172e5a624849/1586269498127/Daimon.pdf

17.

Dawide

Zeleke

Ebro

(2022) Impact of khat production and marketing on the livelihood of smallholder households in Ethiopia. Agricultural Sciences 13: 1309–1320.

18.

DDA BoFED (2017) Development Indicators of Dire Dawa Administration From 2009/10–2015/16. Dire Dawa, Ethiopia: DDA BoFED.

19.

Dube

(2021a) Evaluating urban employment dynamics in selected secondary cities of Ethiopia: a shift-share analysis. Ethiopian Renaissance Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities 8(2): 146–166.

20.

Dube

(2021b) Motivations and livelihood dynamics in the urban informal economy: the case of Dire Dawa City, Eastern Ethiopia. Bulletin of Geography. Socio-Economic Series 51(51): 61–74.

21.

Dube

Mulugeta

(2020) Analysis of socioeconomic vulnerability of street vendors: case study for Dire Dawa City, Eastern Ethiopia. Theoretical and Empirical Researches in Urban Management 15(2): 49–65.

22.

Dube

Mulugeta

Brown

(2021) Governing urban informality in an era of change: street trading in Dire Dawa, Ethiopia. Journal of Urban Development Studies 1(2): 10–27.

23.

Dzawanda

Nicolau

Matsa

, et al. (2023) Livelihood outcomes of informal cross border traders prior to the rise of the virtual cash economy in Gweru, Zimbabwe. Journal of Borderlands Studies 38: 75–94.

24.

Easterly

(2017) Capital city of contraband: how a railroad made and unmade an Ethiopian city. Available at: https://urbandemos.nyu.edu/2017/12/04/capital-city-of-contraband/#:~:text=Politics%20of%20Housing-,Capital%20City%20of%20Contraband%3A%20How%20a%20Railroad,and%20Unmade%20an%20Ethiopian%20City&text=The%20Ethiopia%2DDjibouti%20railway%20has,source%20of%20livelihood%2C%20a%20resource

25.

Endale

(2018) Transacting in the shade. Ethiopian Business Review, 16 September–15 October, no. 66. Available at: https://ethiopianbusinessreview.net/transacting-in-the-shade/ (accessed December 2020).

26.

Esayas

Mulugeta

(2014) Analysis of the changing functional structure of major urban centers of Ethiopia. Ethiopian Journal of Business and Economics 4(2): 220–250.

27.

Ethiopian Business Review (EBR) (2013) The Emerging city how Dire Dawa is creating a post contraband economic identity. Ethiopian Business Review, 13 November. Available at: http://ethiopianbusinessreview.net (accessed November 2015).

28.

Ethiopian Customs and Revenue Authority (ECRA) (2020) Estimated Value of Goods Seized at Major Custom Posts of Ethiopia. Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: ECRA.

29.

Feyisa

Aune

(2003) Khat expansion in the Ethiopian highlands effects on the farming system in Habro district. Mountain Research and Development 23(2): 185–189.

30.

Feyissa

Hoehne

(eds) (2010) Borders and Borderlands as Resources in the Horn of Africa. Woodbridge: Boydell & Brewer.

31.

Feyissa

Midega

Wakjira

(2018) Expectations and belonging in Dire Dawa: drivers, dynamics and challenges of rural to urban mobility, research and evidence facility, EU trust fund for the Horn of Africa. Available at: 1226_1527500554_expectations-and-belonging-in-dire-dawa-by-dereje-feyissa-rvi-2018.pdf (ecoi.net) (accessed December 2020).

32.

Gebissa

(2004) Leaf of Allah: Khat and Agricultural Transformation in Harerge, Ethiopia 1875–1991. Oxford: James Currey.

33.

Hughes

(2019) The Battle for the Horn of Africa: Retrospective. London: Defence Studies Department, Kings College London. Available at: https://defenceindepth.co/2019/02/19/the-battle-for-the-horn-of-africa-a-retrospective/ (accessed June 2022).

34.

International Labour Organization (ILO) (2018) Women and Men in the Informal Economy: A Statistical Picture. 3rd ed. Geneva: ILO.

35.

International Organization of Migration (IOM) (2019) Ethiopia National Displacement Report: Round 19, September–October 2019. Geneva: IOM. Available at: https://displacement.iom.int/sites/default/files/public/reports/DTM%20Ethiopia%20R19%20National%20Displacement%20Report%20v4.pdf (accessed June 2022).

36.

Jonga

(2012) Street vending at Megenagna (Ethiopia): challenges and prospects. Review of Management Innovation and Creativity 5(15): 50–69.

37.

Kahiya

Kadirov

(2020) Informal cross border trade as a substratum marketing system: a review and conceptual framework. Journal of Macromarketing 40(1): 88–109.

38.

Kefale

(2014) Ethnic decentralization and the challenges of inclusive governance in multiethnic cities: the case of Dire Dawa, Ethiopia. Regional & Federal Studies 24(5): 589–605.

39.

Kefale

(2019) Shoats and Smart-Phones: Cross-Border Trading in the Ethio-Somaliland Corridor. Copenhagen: Danish Institute for International Studies.

40.

Little

Waktole

Dejene

(2015) Formal or informal, legal or illegal: the ambiguous nature of cross-border livestock trade in the Horn of Africa. Journal of Borderlands Studies 30(3): 405–421.

41.

Lyons

Brown

(2010) Has mercantilism reduced urban poverty in SSA? Perception of boom, bust, and the China–Africa trade in Lomé and Bamako. World Development 38(5): 771–782.

42.

Mackie

Brown

Dickenson

(2018) Informal economies, conflict recovery and absent aid. Environment & Urbanization 29(2): 365–382.

43.

Mariam

(1964) The background of the Ethio-Somalian boundary dispute. Journal of Modern African Studies 2(2): 189–219.

44.

Matshanda

(2016) Territorial control and cross border movement in Eastern Ethiopia: the case of Togochale border. African Human Mobility Review 2(2): 468–488.

45.

Meagher

(2003) A back door to Globalization? Structural adjustment, globalization and transborder trade in West Africa. Review of African Political Economy 30(95): 57–75.

46.

Ministry of Revenue (MoR) (2017) National Contraband Defence Task Force Plan (Amharic Version). Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: MoR.

47.

Mohamadain

Hassan

(2015) Informal cross-border trade in Eastern Sudan a case study from Kassala and Gedarif states. Sudan Working paper no. 6. Bergen: Chr. Michelsen Institute.

48.

Mpondi

Mupakati

(2018) Migration trajectories and experiences of Zimbabwean immigrants in the Limpopo province of South Africa: impediments and possibilities. Journal of Pan African Studies 12(1): 215.

49.

Pankhurst

(1965) The trade of the Gulf of Aden ports of Africa in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Journal of Ethiopian Studies 3(1): 36–81.

50.

Peberdy

Crush

Teveral

, et al. (2015) Calibrating Informal Cross-Border Trade in Southern Africa. Cape Town, South Africa: Southern African Migration Programme (SAMP).

51.

Rice

(2009) Ethiopia ends Somalia occupation. The Guardian, 26 January. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/jan/26/ethiopia-ends-somalia-occupation (accessed June 2022).

52.

Richards

Bekele

(2015) Conflict in the Somali Region of Ethiopia: Can Education Promote Peace-Building? Boston, MA: Feinstein International Center, Tufts University.

53.

Roever

Linares

(2010) Street Vendor Organising: The Case of the Women’s Network (Red de Mujures). Lima, Peru: WIEGO.

54.

Rutherford

(2008) An unsettled belonging: Zimbabwean farm workers in Limpopo Province, South Africa. Journal of Contemporary African Studies 26(4): 401–415.

55.

Tefera

(2009) Supply response, local reality and livelihood sustainability: the policy dilemma of khat (Catha edulis) production in eastern Ethiopia. International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability 7(3): 176–188.

56.

The Conversation (2018) How events in Ethiopia will influence the Horn of Africa, 15 November. Available at: https://theconversation.com/how-events-in-ethiopia-will-influence-the-horn-of-africa-106631

57.

The World Bank (2019) The World Bank in Ethiopia. Washington, DC: The World Bank.

58.

Titeca

Kimanuka

(2012) Walking in the Dark: Informal Cross-Border Trade in the Great Lakes Region. London: International Alert

59.

UN-Habitat (2008) Ethiopia: Dire Dawa Urban Profile. Nairobi, Kenya: Un-Habitat.

60.

UNHCR (2013) Smuggling and trafficking from the East and Horn of Africa. UNHCR. Available at: https://www.refworld.org/pdfid/5437a14d4.pdf (accessed June 2020).

61.

Yalew

Gebreamilack

(2016) An economic perspective of the historic relationship between Dire Dawa and Djibouti since 1900s. International Journal of Sciences: Basic and Applied Research 30(4): 11–23.

62.

Zemzem

Teklu

(2017) Challenges of cross-border contraband Goods control in Ethiopia revenue and customs authority: the case of humera customs station office. European Journal of Business and Management 9(13): 80–86.