Does Tax Increment Financing Deliver on Its Promise of Jobs? The Impact of Tax Increment Financing on Municipal Employment Growth

Abstract

Increasingly, municipal leaders justify their use of tax increment financing (TIF) by touting its role in improving municipal employment. However, empirical studies on TIF have primarily examined TIF’s impact on property values, ignoring the claim that serves as the primary justification for its use. This article addresses the claim by examining the impact of TIF adoption on municipal employment growth in Illinois, looking for both general impact and impact specific to the type of development supported. Results find no general impact of TIF use on employment. However, findings suggest that TIF districts supporting industrial development may have a positive effect on municipal employment, whereas TIF districts supporting retail development have a negative effect on municipal employment. These results are consistent with industrial TIF districts capturing employment that would have otherwise occurred outside of the adopting municipality and retail TIF districts shifting employment within the municipality to more labor-efficient retailers within the TIF district.

Keywords

tax increment financing employment economic development incentives state and local taxation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Almada, J. ( 1999, October 17). Re-distribution. Proposed produce market may be new home for S. Water market. Chicago Tribune, sec. Real Estate, p. 4.

Almada, J. ( 2002a, April 21). 3 neighborhoods share in new TIF. Chicago Tribune, sec. Real Estate, p. 3A.

Almada, J. ( 2002b, June 23). TIF proposal is aimed at renewing East 79th . Chicago Tribune, sec. Real Estate, p. 7P.

Anderson, J.E. ( 1990). Tax increment financing: Municipal adoption and growth . National Tax Journal, 43, 155-163.

Byrne, P.F. ( 2005). Strategic interaction and the adoption of tax increment financing. Regional Science and Urban Economics, 35, 279-303.

Byrne, P.F. ( 2006). Determinants of property value growth for tax increment financing districts. Economic Development Quarterly, 20, 317-329.

Council of Development Finance Agencies. ( 2007). Tax increment finance best practices reference guide . Cleveland, OH: Author.

Council of Development Finance Agencies. ( 2008). 2008 TIF state-by-state report. Retrieved June 5, 2009, from http://www.cdfa.net/cdfa/cdfaweb.nsf/fbaad5956b2928b086256efa005c5f78/6f8fca63dc04444b8625752700572be3/$FILE/CDFA-2008-TIF-State-By-State-Report.pdf

Dardick, H. ( 2002, July 10). Petitions oppose North Aurora TIF home-buying plan. Chicago Tribune, sec. Trib West, p. 6.

10.

Dye, R.F. , & Merriman, D.F. (2000). The effects of tax increment financing on economic development. Journal of Urban Economics , 47, 306-328.

11.

Economic Development Corporation of Kansas City. ( 2009). 2008 Kansas City Missouri tax increment financing annual report. Retrieved June, 12, 2009, from https://www.edckc.com/tif/annrpts/00104124.PDF

12.

Elkins, K. ( 2005, February 18). North Carolina’s new deal: With tax-increment financing now in their war chest, state’s developers sharpen pitch. Charlotte Business Journal.

13.

Kadin, D. ( 1996a, August 7). Hearing slated on plan to set up TIF for a mall. Chicago Tribune, sec. Metro DuPage, p. 3.

14.

Kadin, D. ( 1996b, August 20). Residents upset with retail project. Chicago Tribune, sec. Metro DuPage, p. 2.

15.

Kuczka, S. ( 1995, August 8). Tiny village tries to gain muscle. Chicago Tribune, sec. Metro Lake, p. 1.

16.

Man, J.Y. , & Rosentraub, M.S. (1998). Tax increment financing: municipal adoption and effects on property value growth. Public Finance Review, 26, 523-547.

17.

Martin, A. ( 1998, January 23). Daley pugs for 5 tax districts to lure back business. TIF list includes 156 vacant sites. Chicago Tribune, sec. Metro Chicago, p. 5.

18.

O’Brien, K. ( 2000, April 27). Advisory panel endorses TIF plan. Chicago Tribune, sec. Metro Southwest, p. 1.

19.

Rusin, C. ( 1997, December 24). Proposed TIF could mean new business, jobs . Chicago Tribune, sec. McHenry County, p. 2.

20.

Smith, B. ( 2006). The impact of tax increment finance districts on localized real estate: Evidence from Chicago’s multifamily markets. Journal of Housing Economics, 15, 21-37.

21.

Washburn, G. ( 1997, October 8). City officials seeking TIF designation for 6 industrial areas. Chicago Tribune, sec. Metro Chicago, p. 6.

22.

Washburn, G. , & Martin, A. ( 1997, November 5). Daley springs to the defense of city’s TIFs. Tax districts spurring development, mayor contends. Chicago Tribune, sec. Metro Chicago, p. 1.

23.

Weber, R. , Bhatta, S. , & Merriman, D. ( 2003). Does tax increment financing raise urban industrial property values? Urban Studies, 40, 2001-2021.

24.

West Virginia Development Office. (2003). Property tax increment financing in West Virginia: A guide for counties and class I and II municipalities. Retrieved June, 5, 2009, from http://www.state.wv.us/taxrev/uploads/tifhandbook.pdf

25.

Wooldridge, J.M. ( 2001). Econometric analysis of cross-section and panel data . Boston, MA: MIT Press.