This article discusses the international response to the conflict in Darfur from 2003 onwards in order to explore some of the key challenges related to implementing the responsibility to protect (R2P). First, we show that the debates on R2P in connection to Darfur translated into little more substantive action than the pragmatic decision to deploy peace operations with mandates that included civilian protection, as suggested by the African Union (AU) Mission in Sudan (AMIS), and later by the hybrid UN—AU Mission in Darfur (UNAMID). Second, we argue that the international response to Darfur illustrates three major challenges to R2P implementation. These are: political limitations inherent in the R2P framework; moral dilemmas emerging from military action; and tactical challenges, as exemplified by the struggles faced by the AU and the UN in Darfur. We conclude that the international failure to offer meaningful protection in Darfur highlights the need for continued caution and critical analysis of the ways in which R2P is conceptualized and implemented.
Abass, Ademola, 2007. `The United Nations, the African Union and the Darfur Crisis: Of Apology and Utopia', Netherlands International Law Review54: 434-435.
2.
Adada, Rodolphe, 2008. `The U.N. Is Making a Difference in Darfur', Wall Street Journal, 25 June.
3.
African Union, 2004. `Report of the Chairperson of the AU Commission', PSC/PR/2(XVII), 20 October.
4.
African Union, 2005. `Briefing Note on the Renewal of the Mandate of the AU Mission in the Sudan (AMIS)' , PSC/PR/2(XLII), 20 October.
5.
Annan, Kofi, 1999. `Two Concepts of Sovereignty', The Economist , 18 September.
6.
Ayoob, Mohammed, 2004. `Third World Perspectives on Humanitarian Intervention and International Administration', Global Governance10(1): 99-118.
7.
Badescu, Cristina G., 2007. `Authorizing Humanitarian Intervention: Hard Choices in Saving Strangers', Canadian Journal of Political Science40(1): 51-78.
8.
Badescu, Cristina G., forthcoming. `"The Responsibility To Protect": Embracing Sovereignty and Human Rights', in Noha Shawki & Michaelene Cox, eds, Negotiating Sovereignty and Human Rights: Actors and Issues in Contemporary Human Rights Politics. Farnham: Ashgate.
9.
BBC News (London), 2004. `Frustration of Darfur "Observer"', 14 November; available at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/4007117.stm (accessed 22 March 2009).
10.
Beaumont, Peter, 2006. `Darfur Terror Chief Slips into Britain', The Observer, 12 March.
11.
Bellamy, Alex J., 2005. `Responsibility To Protect or Trojan Horse? The Crisis in Darfur and Humanitarian Intervention After Iraq', Ethics and International Affairs19(2): 31-53.
12.
Bellamy, Alex J., 2006. `Whither the Responsibility To Protect? Humanitarian Intervention and the 2005 World Summit', Ethics and International Affairs20(2): 143-169.
13.
Brunnee, Junta & Stephen J. Toope , 2006. `Norms, Institutions and UN Reform: The Responsibility To Protect', Behind the Headlines63(3). Toronto: Canadian Institute of International Affairs .
14.
Cohen, Roberta & William O'Neill , 2006. `Last Stand in Sudan?', Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists61(2): 51-58.
Darfur Consortium, 2008. `Putting People First: The Protection Challenge Facing UNAMID in Darfur'. Kampala: Darfur Consortium; available at http://www.darfurconsortium.org/darfur_consortium_actions/reports/2008/Putting_People_First_UNAMID_report.pdf (accessed 2 February 2009).
17.
Deen, Thalif, 2008. `Caught Between Peacekeeping And Development', Inter Press Service, 11 March.
18.
Deng, Francis M., 1995. `Frontiers of Sovereignty', Leiden Journal of International Law8(2): 249-286.
19.
Deng, Francis M.; Sadikiel Kimaro, Terrence Lyons, Donald Rothchild & I. William Zartman , 1996. Sovereignty as Responsibility: Conflict Management in Africa. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
20.
de Waal, Alex, 2005. `Who are the Darfurians? Arab and African Identities, Violence and External Engagement', African Affairs104(415): 181-205.
21.
de Waal, Alex, 2006. `The Book Was Closed Too Soon on Peace in Darfur' , The Guardian, 29 September.
22.
de Waal, Alex, 2007. `Darfur and the Failure of the Responsibility To Protect' , International Affairs83(6): 1039-1054.
23.
de Waal, Alex & Julie Flint, 2006. Darfur: A Short History of a Long War. London: Zed.
24.
Fadul, Abdul-Jabbar & Victor Tanner , 2007. `Darfur After Abuja: A View from the Ground', in Alex de Waal, ed., War in Darfur and the Search for Peace. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press (284-313).
25.
Falk, Richard A., 1993. `Intervention Revisited: Hard Choices and Tragic Dilemmas' , The Nation21(257): 755-764.
26.
Grono, Nick, 2006. `The International Community's Failure To Protect' , African Affairs105(421): 621-631.
27.
Guardian, The (London), 2008. `Sudan Warns West of "Iraq-Style Disaster" in Darfur', 12 March.
28.
Henshaw, Amber, 2008. `Darfur Force "May Last 10 Years"', BBC News, 12 March; available at http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/7292658.stm (accessed 22 March 2009).
29.
Hoge, Warren, 2008. `Intervention, Hailed as a Concept, But Shunned in Practice' , New York Times, 8 January.
30.
Holt, Victoria K. & Tobias C. Berkman , 2006. The Impossible Mandate? Military Preparedness, The Responsibility To Protect, and Modern Peace Operations . Washington, DC: Henry Stimson Center.
31.
Human Rights Watch, 2006. Sudan: Imperatives for Immediate Change - The African Union Mission in Sudan. New York: Human Rights Watch.
32.
International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty (ICISS), 2001. The Responsibility To Protect: Report of the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty . Ottawa: International Development Research Centre.
33.
International Crisis Group (ICG), 2004. Darfur Deadline: A New International Action Plan, Africa Briefing 83. Nairobi/Brussels: ICG.
34.
International Crisis Group (ICG), 2006. To Save Darfur, Africa Report 105. Nairobi/ Brussels: ICG.
35.
International Crisis Group (ICG), 2007. Darfur's New Security Reality, Africa Report 134. Nairobi /Brussels: ICG.
36.
International Peace Academy (IPA), 2007. The AU in Sudan: Lessons for the African Standby Force. New York: IPA.
37.
Johnstone, Ian & Alhaji Bah , 2007. `Peacekeeping in Sudan: The Dynamics of Protection, Partnerships and Inclusive Politics', Occasional Paper . New York: Center on International Cooperation.
38.
Lusk, Gill, 2008. `False Premise and False Response to the Darfur Crisis' , Peace Review20(2): 166-174.
39.
Mamdani, Mahmood, 2007. `The Politics of Naming: Genocide, Civil War, Insurgency' , London Review of Books, 29 March.
40.
Mepham, David & Alexander Ramsbotham, eds, 2006. Darfur: The Responsibility To Protect, London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
41.
Natsios, Andrew S., 2008. `Beyond Darfur. Sudan's Slide Toward Civil War' , The Council on Foreign Relations87(3): 77-93.
42.
O'Neill, William G. & Violette Cassis , 2005. Protecting Two Million Displaced: The Successes and Shortcomings of the African Union in Darfur. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.
43.
Pace, William & Nicole Deller , 2005. `Preventing Future Genocides: An International Responsibility To Protect', World Order36(4): 15-32.
44.
Prendergast, John, 2006. `So How Come We Haven't Stopped It?', The Washington Post, 19 November.
45.
Prunier, Gerard, 2007. Darfur: The Ambiguous Genocide?, rev. edn. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
46.
Reuters, 2008. `Darfur Attacks Increase Local Doubts over UN', 22 February.
47.
Rice, Susan E.; Anthony Lake & Donald M. Payne , 2006. `We Saved Europeans. Why Not Africans?', Washington Post, 2 October.
48.
Security Council Report, 2008. `Protection of Civilians', Cross-Cutting Report No. 2, 14 October; available at http://www.securitycouncilreport.org/atf/cf/%7B65BFCF9B6D27-4E9C-8CD3-CF6E4FF96FF9%7D/XCuttingPOC2008.pdf (accessed 16 March 2009).
49.
Slim, Hugo, 2004. `Dithering over Darfur? A Preliminary Review of the International Response', International Affairs80(5): 811-828.
50.
Thakur, Ramesh, 2006. The United Nations, Peace and Security: From Collective Security to the Responsibility To Protect. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
51.
United Nations, 1998. `Report of the Secretary-General on the Situation in Africa', S/1998/318, 13 April.
52.
United Nations, 1999. `Annual Report of the Secretary-General to the General Assembly', SG/SM/7136 GA/9596, 20 September.
53.
United Nations, 2002. Aide-Mémoire Attached as Annex to UN Security Council Presidential Statement, S/PRST/2002/6.
54.
United Nations, 2004. `Report of the Secretary General on the Sudan', S/2004/881, 2 November.
55.
United Nations, 2005a. `Report of the International Commission of Inquiry on Darfur to the United Nations Secretary-General', Geneva, 25 January.
56.
United Nations, 2005b. `Report of the Secretary-General on U.N. Assistance to the A.U. Mission in the Sudan' , S/2005/285, 3 May.
57.
United Nations, 2005c. `World Summit Outcome Document', A/60/L.1, 15 September.
58.
United Nations, 2007a. `Letter Dated 23 May 2007 from the Secretary-General Addressed to the President of the Security Council', S/2007/307, 24 May.
59.
United Nations, 2007b. `Report of the Secretary-General and the Chairperson of the AU Commission on the Hybrid Operation in Darfur ', S/2007/307 Rev.1, 5 June.
60.
United Nations, 2007c. `62nd General Assembly Fifth Committee Meeting', GA/AB/3828, 19 November.
61.
United Nations, 2008. `Report of the Secretary-General on the Deployment of the African Union-United Nations Hybrid Operation in Darfur ', S/2008/781, 12 December.
62.
United Nations, 2009. `Implementing the Responsibility To Protect', Report of the Secretary-General, A/63/677, 12 January.
63.
United Nations News, 2008a. `Rwanda: Ban Ki-Moon Says World Must Protect Civilians from Genocide', 29 January.
64.
United Nations News, 2008b. `Darfur: Stepped Up Attacks on Food Trucks Could Shut Down Deliveries, UN Warns', 7 September.
65.
Weiss, Thomas G., 2007. Humanitarian Intervention: Ideas in Action. Cambridge: Polity.
66.
Wheeler, Nicholas J., 2000. Saving Strangers: Humanitarian Intervention in International Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
67.
Wheeler, Nicholas J., 2005. `A Victory for Common Humanity? The Responsibility To Protect After the 2005 World Summit', paper presented at the conference `The UN at Sixty: Celebration or Wake?', University of Toronto, 6-7 October.
68.
Williams, Paul D., 2006. `Military Responses to Mass Killing: The African Union Mission in Sudan', International Peacekeeping13(2): 168-183.
69.
Williams, Paul D., 2007. `From Non-Intervention to Non-Indifference', African Affairs106(423): 253-279.
70.
Williams, Paul & Alex Bellamy, 2005. `The Responsibility To Protect and the Crisis in Darfur ', Security Dialogue36(1): 27-47.
71.
Withington, Thomas, 2008. Grounded: The International Community's Betrayal of UNAMID, a joint NGO report endorsed by a consortium of NGOs; available at http://darfur.3cdn.net/b5b2056f1398299ffe_x9m6bt7cu.pdf (accessed 1 February 2009).
