Nodular Cast Iron—its Present Position and Future Prospects as an Engineering Material,with Special Reference to its Suitability for Crankshafts

Abstract

The historical development of iron having graphite present in the nodular form as cast, is traced from the patent application by Morrogh and the British Cast Iron Research Association (1946)† to its selection as a crankshaft material by the Ford Motor Co. in 1952. The economics of the production of nodular iron by various methods is discussed and it is concluded that material produced by the magnesium-nickel process now in use cannot compete in price with established materials such as carbon steel and malleable iron. Methods for direct addition of magnesium to molten iron are described, and it is concluded that application of these methods to low-sulphur irons from basic cupolas may completely alter the situation.

The engineering properties of nodular cast iron are compared with those of other ferrous metals. It is concluded that nodular irons in the as-cast condition may be used instead of high grade flake-graphite irons for components not subject to shock loading, and instead of malleable irons in applications where 2–4 per cent elongation at fracture is adequate. The annealed nodular cast irons may be used, where their extra ductility and impact resistance are considered essential, to replace malleable irons and cast or forged carbon-steels. Their chief advantage over malleable irons lies in the shorter heat-treatment they require, which becomes economically more important as the size of a casting increases and as its selling price per lb. falls. As a replacement for carbon steel, nodular cast iron will be attractive for components which are difficult to cast or which require high surface-hardness with medium strength and impact resistance. However, the extent to which nodular cast iron replaces any of these materials will be determined largely by the price at which it can be produced; this will have to be decreased very considerably before it becomes competitive. Ultimate output of nodular cast iron in Britain in peace time is likely to be limited by the high cost of the low-phosphorus ore which is necessary for its production; in war time, its output might be severely restricted by the difficulty in importing this ore.

The particular application of nodular cast iron to crankshafts is discussed in detail. It can replace alloy flake-graphite irons with a gain in ductility and impact resistance, and is already replacing graphitic cast steel, chiefly because of its better founding properties, and because its lower pouring-temperature facilitates the use of mass-produced shell moulds. It seems doubtful whether its fatigue properties will permit of its replacing the forged low-alloy steel which is used for most British automobile crankshafts, unless some reduction in engine specific-power output is accepted.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Foundrymen's Association 1944 ‘Cast Metals Handbook’.

Berdyanskaya

M. G.

Tsymbal

A. G.

Adamski

V. A.

1951 Sel'khozmashina, 1951, No. 5, p. 23, ‘An Experiment of the Red Star Factory in the Production of Cast Iron with Spheroidal Graphite’.

Bogan

L. C.

1952 ‘The Status, Development, and Possible Australian Future of Spheroidal Graphite Cast Irons’, paper presented before the Australian Institute of Metals, Newcastle Branch, 15th October. (Reprinted in The Australasian Engineer, March, April, May 1953.).

British Cast Iron Research Association 1951 ‘Improvements in the Manufacture of Cast Iron’, British Patent No. 688,588 (application date, 7th February 1951).

British Commonwealth Scientific Office (North America) 1953 ‘B.C.S.O. Review of Science in the U.S.A. for the Year Ending 30th June 1952’ (H.M. Stationery Office).

British Standards Institution 1933 B.S. No. 131, ‘British Standard Forms of Notched Bar Test Pieces’.

1948 B.S. No. 1452, ‘Grey Iron Castings’.

1950 B.S. No. 971, ‘Commentary on British Standard Wrought Steels, En Series’.

British Steel Founders’ Association 1953 Proc. First Customer/Founder Convention, London, April.

10.

Buckley

1953 Proc. I.Mech.E., vol. 167, p. 177, ‘Developments in Steel Castings in the Heavy Power Plant Industry’.

11.

Cape

Cheetham

J. H.

1946 ‘Report on Shock Tests of Paxman R.Q. Engine Crankshafts’, British Internal Combustion Engine Research Association, Research Report No. 46/4.

12.

Collins

W. L.

Smith

J. O.

1942 A.S.M.E., vol. 42, p. 639, ‘The Notch Sensitivity of Alloyed Cast Irons Subjected to Repeated and Static Loads’.

13.

Cone

E. F.

1935 Metals and Alloys, vol. 6, p. 259, ‘The Story of the Ford Cast Crankshaft’.

14.

1940 Metals and Alloys, vol. 12, p. 267, ‘Ford Cast Steel Crankshafts now Poured Continuously’.

15.

Cornelius

1940 Die Giesserei, vol. 27, p. 491, ‘The Behaviour of Cast Crankshaft Materials During Fatigue Testing in Bending and Torsion’.

16.

Everest

A. B.

1951 ‘Cast Iron Crankshafts, with Special Reference to Acicular and Spheroidal Graphite Cast Irons’, Congrès International Des Moteurs, Paris.

17.

1952 ‘The Engineering Properties and Applications of Spheroidal Graphite Cast Iron’, Fourth International Mechanical Engineering Congress, Stockholm, June.

18.

Gilbert

G. N. J.

1952 ‘Fatigue Properties of Cast Iron—Progress Report’, British Cast Iron Research Association Report No. E.42 (unpublished).

19.

1953 ‘The Ductility of Ferritic Nodular Cast Iron’, British Cast Iron Research Association, Research Report No. 348, B.C.I.R.A. Journal of Research and Development, vol. 4, No. 10.

20.

Gough

H. J.

Pollard

H. V.

1936–37 Proc. Inst. Automobile Eng., vol. 31, p. 821, ‘Properties of Some Materials for Cast Crankshafts’.

21.

Gough

H. J.

Pollard

H. V.

Clenshaw

W. J.

1951 ‘Some Experiments on the Resistance of Metals to Fatigue Under Combined Stresses’, Aeronautical Research Council, Reports and Memoranda 2522 (H.M. Stationery Office).

22.

Grant

J. W.

1950 ‘Notched and Un-notched Fatigue Tests on Flake and Nodular Cast Irons’, British Cast Iron Research Association, Research Report No. 251, B.C.I.R.A. Journal of Research and Development, vol. 3, No. 5, p. 333.

23.

1952a ‘Fatigue Properties of Cast Iron—First Progress Report’, British Cast Iron Research Association Report No. E.32 (unpublished).

24.

1952b ‘Some Damping Tests on Flake and Nodular Graphite Irons’, British Cast Iron Research Association Report No. E.33 (unpublished).

25.

Hatfield

W. H.

Stanfield

Rotherham

1942 Trans. North East Coast Inst. Eng. and Shipbuilders, vol. 58, p. 273, ‘The Damping Capacity of Engineering Materials’.

26.

Hatfield

W. H.

Rotherham

Harvey

M. A.

1944 Trans. North East Coast Inst. Eng. and Shipbuilders, vol. 60, p. 227, ‘Further Experiments on the Damping Capacity of Metals’.

27.

Higgins

R. I.

1952 ‘Shellmoulding in the U.S.A.’, British Commonwealth Scientific Office (North America), Report No. 840.

28.

High Duty Alloys, Ltd. 1953 ‘Hiduminium Technical Data’.

29.

Klauzen

A. I.

1951 Sel'khozmashina, 1951, No. 8, p. 29, ‘Introduction of High Strength Cast Iron with Spheroidal Graphite in Construction of Agricultural Machinery’.

30.

Longaretti

Noris

1952 Fonderia Italiana, vol. 1, No. 1, p. 3, ‘A New Low-cost Process for the Industrial Production of Nodular Iron’. (English translation, Trans. Am. Foundrymen's Soc., vol. 60, p. 101.).

31.

Love

R. J.

1950 ‘Fatigue Strength of Cast Crankshafts: First Report on the Influence of Crankshaft Material on Bending Fatigue Strength’, Motor Industry Research Assoc., Report No. 1950/2.

32.

1951 ‘The Influence of Crankshaft Material on Bending Fatigue Strength—Second Report: Four Cast Steels’, Motor Industry Research Assoc., Report No. 1951/14.

33.

1952 ‘The Influence of Crankshaft Material on Bending Fatigue Strength—Third Report: Four Nodular Graphite Irons’, Motor Industry Research Assoc., Report No. 1952/1.

34.

1953 ‘Torsional Fatigue Strength of Cast Crankshafts: A Comparison of Four Materials’, Motor Industry Research Association Report No. 1953/1.

35.

Macassey

Cooper

1951 ‘Report on the Crankshaft “Bottleneck” in the Internal Combustion Engine Industry’, British Internal Combustion Engine Manufacturers’ Assoc., Report No. BG 1265 (unpublished).

36.

Magnesium Elektron, Ltd. 1953 ‘Elektron Magnesium-Zirconium Cast and Wrought Alloys’.

37.

Millis

K. D.

Gagnebin

A. P.

Pilling

N. B.

1947 ‘Cast Ferrous Alloy’, United States Patent No. 2,485,760 (application date, 21st November 1947).

38.

Ministry of Supply 1953 ‘Iron and Steel Prices Order, Deposited Schedule No. 78A.—Steel Forgings (Part A)’, 14th March.

39.

Mond Nickel Co. 1947 ‘Improvements Relating to Cast Iron’, British Patent No. 630,070 (application date, 22nd March 1947).

40.

Moore

H. F.

1926 ‘Tests of the Fatigue Strength of Cast Steel’, University of Illinois Bulletin, vol. 23, No. 44, Engineering Experiment Station Bulletin No. 156.

41.

Morrogh

1948 ‘Improvements in or Relating to the Production of Cast Irons’, British Patent No. 654,911 (application date, 30th October 1948).

42.

1952 ‘The Harmful Influence of Some Residual Elements in Magnesium Treated Nodular Cast Irons, and their Neutralisation by Cerium’, British Cast Iron Res. Assoc., Research Report No. 334. B.C.I.R.A. Jl. of Research and Development, vol. 4, No. 5, p. 292.

43.

Morrogh, H., and the British Cast Iron Research Association 1946 ‘Improvements Relating to the Manufacture of Cast Iron’, British Patent No. 645,862 (application date, 22nd July 1946).

44.

Neuber

1937 ‘Kerbspannungslehre’ (J. Springer, Berlin). (English translation 1945 ‘Theory of Notch Stresses: Principles for Exact Stress Calculation’, United States Navy, David W. Taylor Model Basin, Translation 74, by F. A. Raven, annotated by J. S. Brock.).

45.

Palmer

K. B.

Gilbert

G. N. J.

1953 ‘The Fatigue Properties of Nodular Cast Iron’, British Cast Iron Research Assoc., Research Report No. 361. B.C.I.R.A. Jl. of Research and Development, vol. 5, No. 1.

46.

Phillips

C. E.

Heywood

R. B.

1951 Proc. I.Mech.E., vol. 165, p. 113, ‘The Size Effect in Fatigue of Plain and Notched Steel Specimens Loaded Under Reversed Direct Stress’.

47.

Product Engineering 1942 vol. 13, p. 37, ‘Malleable Cast Iron’.

48.

Saunders

M. S.

Sinnott

M. J.

1953 Trans. Am. Soc. Metals, vol. 45, p. 362, ‘Some Properties of Nodular Iron at Elevated Temperatures’.

49.

Shannon

J. F.

1935 Proc. I.Mech.E., vol. 131, p. 387, ‘Damping Influences in Torsional Oscillation’.

50.

Steel Founders’ Society of America 1950 ‘Steel Castings Handbook’.

51.

Tapsell

H. J.

Clenshaw

W. J.

1927 D.S.I.R. Engineering Research Special Reports Nos. 1 and’ 2, ‘Properties of Materials at High Temperatures’ (H.M. Stationery Office).

52.

Templeton

R. B.

1946 Proc. Inst. Automobile Eng., vol. 41, p. 231, ‘The Production of Cast Crankshafts’.

53.

Thurston

R. C. A.

Field

J. E.

1954 Proc. I.Mech.E., vol. 168, No. 31, p. 785, ‘The Fatigue Strength and Bending, Torsional and Combined Stresses of Steel Test Pieces with Stress Concentrations’.

54.

United States Department of Commerce 1952 ‘Facts for Industry’, Bureau of Census, September 26th.

55.

Williams

C. G.

Brown

J. S.

1940 ‘The Fatigue Strength of Crankshafts’, Inst. Automobile Eng., Automobile Research Committee Report No. 9195B.