Analysis of electromagnetic force and deformation behavior in electromagnetic forming with different coil systems

Abstract

As a high-speed forming technology, electromagnetic forming has been more and more widely used because it can improve the material forming performance greatly. In electromagnetic forming process, the pulsed electromagnetic force generated by the coils is the load of the workpiece, hence its distribution characteristics have a great influence on the workpiece forming performance. Based on the basic principle of electromagnetic forming, this paper introduces and analyzes some latest electromagnetic forming technologies with different coil systems, including electromagnetic incremental forming, space-time-controlled multi-stage pulsed magnetic field forming, and electromagnetic tube expansion with axial compression. Aim at each forming method, the following contents are mainly studied: 1) The key technical problems solved by this method. 2) The structure of the coil system. 3) The distribution of magnetic flux density and electromagnetic force. 4) The advantages and disadvantages of the method. Through above analysis, it is hoped that the basic idea of technological innovation in electromagnetic forming is clarified in this paper, which can provide guidance for the future innovation direction of electromagnetic forming.

Keywords

Electromagnetic forming coil system axial electromagnetic force radial electromagnetic force

1. Introduction

Electromagnetic forming (EMF) is a high speed forming technology using pulsed high magnetic field to apply electromagnetic force on metallic workpiece [1, 2, 3]. Compared with the conventional processing technology, EMF has two obvious advantages. Firstly, because of high strain rate (10 ${}^{3}$ –10 ${}^{5}$ s ${}^{-1}$ ), EMF can improve the material plastic deformation and increase its forming limit by 5–10 times [4]. Secondly, due to the non-contact electromagnetic force, a high surface quality is maintained and the stress concentration can be reduced during the forming process [5]. At present, EMF has been applied to deform light alloys and weld different material tubes in aerospace field and automobile field, and the forming results show that EMF is one of the effective methods to solve the difficult problems in the processing of light alloy [6].

For development of EMF technology, how to reduce the temperature rise of the coil and how to design a new types of coils with different electromagnetic force distribution for deforming workpiece should be seriously focused [7, 8, 9]. In EMF process, coil system is the actuation of electromagnetic force, whose structure affects the distribution of electromagnetic field and force directly. Psyk et al. point out that the coil system should have high energy conversion efficiency, high mechanical strength, and optimized discharge pulse width [10]. According to the actual workpiece surface characteristics, Tekkaya et al. design a coil system to match the workpiece structure for the improvement of the EMF energy conversion efficiency [11]. Qiu et al. introduce the pulsed high magnetic field technology to EMF, result in the coil mechanical strength and the electromagnetic force generated by the coil system are obviously increased [12]. Cao et al. research the effects of current frequency on the electromagnetic sheet forming process, the obtained results show that the optimal current frequency is related to the relative skin depth of the workpiece, and find that there are two better current frequencies for different relative skin depth [13]. Kamal proposes a new coil system named uniform pressure electromagnetic actuator, which can produce relatively uniform electromagnetic force in the workpiece [14]. A U-shaped external conductor is required to form a closed secondary circuit with the workpiece in uniform pressure electromagnetic forming process. The above studies have solved some basic technical problems in EMF, hence the applications of new coil system with special electromagnetic force distribution should be noted for development of EMF technology.

The rest of the paper is arranged as the following. Section 2 presents the basic principle of EMF process. Sections 3–5 present the three typical technology respectively. Section 6 concludes this paper.

2. Basic principle

EMF equipment mainly includes charging system, capacitor, discharge switch, coil system, and workpiece, as shown in Fig. 1. Firstly, the capacitor is charged by the charging system. Secondly, the stored energy is loaded into the coil system through the discharge switch to generate a pulse large current and a pulse strong magnetic field around the workpiece. Thirdly, the variational magnetic field produces induced eddy current in the workpiece. Finally, the electromagnetic force between the pulse current in the coil system and the induced eddy current in the workpiece drives the workpiece instantly accelerated and deformed [15]. Usually, EMF is divided into electromagnetic tube forming and electromagnetic sheet forming [16, 17, 18]. According to the different workpiece geometric structure, the tube is deformed by using helix coil system in EMF process, while the sheet is deformed by using spiral coil system.

Figure 1.

Diagram of EMF equipment. (a) basic principle, (b) electromagnetic tube forming, (c) electromagnetic sheet forming.

Figure 2.

Magnetic flux density and electromagnetic fore in electromagnetic sheet forming process.

Ignoring the influence of the asymptotic line, spiral coil system and helix coil system can be equivalent to a plurality of radially distributed closed rings and axially distributed closed rings respectively. And then, the coil system, the workpiece, and the electromagnetic field source are all axial symmetrical, hence it can be simplified as a two-dimensional axisymmetric model. The eddy current in the workpiece mainly flows in the hoop direction:

$\displaystyle\nabla\times\bm{E}_{\phi}=-\frac{\partial\bm{B}_{z}}{\partial t}+% \nabla\times\left(\bm{v}_{z}\times\bm{B}_{r}\right)$ (1) $\displaystyle\nabla\times\bm{E}_{\phi}=-\frac{\partial\bm{B}_{z}}{\partial t}+% \nabla\times\left(\bm{v}_{r}\times\bm{B}_{z}\right)$ (2) $\displaystyle\bm{J}_{\phi}=\gamma\bm{E}_{\phi}$ (3)

Where $E$ is the electric field intensity, $B$ is the magnetic flux density, $v$ is the workpiece speed and $J$ is the current density. The subscripts $r$ , $\Phi$ , $z$ denote the radial, hoop and axial component of a vector respectively. The Eqs (1) and (2) represent the curl of the induced electric field produced by the induced electromotive force and the motional electromotive force. The main component of the workpiece velocity in electromagnetic sheet forming process is the axial direction, while that in electromagnetic tube forming process is the radial direction. Thus, the motional electromotive force is determined by the axial velocity and the radial magnetic flux density in electromagnetic sheet forming process (1), while that is determined by the radial velocity and the axial magnetic flux density in electromagnetic tube forming process (2).

The electromagnetic force acting on the workpiece is determined by both the induced eddy current and the magnetic flux density:

$\displaystyle\bm{F}_{z}=\bm{J}_{\phi}\times\bm{B}_{r}$ (4) $\displaystyle\bm{F}_{r}=\bm{J}_{\phi}\times\bm{B}_{z}$ (5)

Figures 2 and 3 show that the electromagnetic force acting on a sheet is mainly in the axial direction Eq. (4), while that acting on a tube is mainly in the radial direction Eq. (5). It is clear that the electromagnetic force is related to the magnetic flux density, whose distribution mainly depends on the geometric structure of the coil system.

Figure 3.

Magnetic flux density and electromagnetic fore in electromagnetic tube forming process.

In electromagnetic sheet forming process, the workpiece is located at one side of the spiral coil system, and the magnetic flux density in this region is extremely uneven, resulting in a uneven distribution of electromagnetic force, as shown in Fig. 2. In electromagnetic tube forming process, the workpiece is located outside or inside the helix coil system, the electromagnetic force is relatively uniform because of the axial symmetry, as shown in Fig. 3.

3. Electromagnetic incremental forming

In conventional electromagnetic sheet forming process, it is difficult to deform large-scale sheet due to the limit of the power capacity and coil geometry size. Combining EMF with digital control, Mo et al. propose a new technology named electromagnetic incremental forming [19]. Figure 4 shows the basic principle of electromagnetic incremental forming. Firstly, a small coil is used to generate local electromagnetic force and deform part of large-scale sheet, and then the large-scale sheet is completely deformed by moving the coil system with computer control.

Figure 4.

Principle of Electromagnetic incremental forming.

Figure 5.

Deformed sheet using Electromagnetic incremental forming. (a) loading path, (b) deformed sheet with 1600 V voltage, (c) deformed sheet with 1600 V $+$ 3500 V voltages [20].

By use of electromagnetic incremental forming, a spiral coil system with inner radius, outer radius, and height of 12 mm, 48 mm, 6 mm respectively is used to deform an AA3003 sheet with a diameter of 280 mm and a thickness of 1 mm [20]. The coil is firstly discharged at 60 mm away from the middle of workpiece, and then it is moved along the loading path as shown in Fig. 5a. Figure 5b shows the deformed sheet by electromagnetic incremental forming. The results show that the sheet has a good moldability with the side surface of the die. It is verified that electromagnetic incremental forming is feasibly to produce a large part with small coil and small discharge energy. However, the workpiece is mainly bulged but slightly flowed in electromagnetic incremental forming process.

Figure 6.

Principle of axial-radial force bi-directionally loaded in double coil electromagnetic forming [22].

Figure 7.

Simulation and experimental results of EMF with double coils for deep drawing. (a) simulation, (b) experiment [23].

4. Space-time-controlled multi-stage pulsed magnetic field forming

To increase the deformation depth, Li et al. propose a method named space-time-controlled multi-Stage pulsed magnetic field forming [21]. Multiple sets of coils with the corresponding power supply are applied to provide a wider space and a longer period of electromagnetic force for workpiece.

A practical application of space-time-controlled multi-stage pulsed magnetic field forming is loading both the axial and radial electromagnetic force on sheet for deep drawing [22, 23]. On the basis of a conventional single-coil EMF (coil 1), a coil system (coil 2) is introduced at the outside of the sheet, as shown in Fig. 6. Coil 1 mainly provides the axial electromagnetic force, while coil 2 mainly provides the radial electromagnetic force. Because of the radial electromagnetic force in the flange of the sheet, the material flow property is increased effectively. Figure 7 shows the simulation and experimental results of EMF with double coils for deep drawing. The results show that the radial displacement of the workpiece in the conventional single-coil EMF is limited, but there is obvious plastic flow when the radial electromagnetic force is introduced. On the whole, space-time-controlled multi-stage pulsed magnetic field forming can enhance the material plastic flow by using multiple sets of coils. But the price is also increased due to the large investment of equipment.

5. Electromagnetic tube expansion with axial compression

Electromagnetic tube forming can be divided into tube expansion and tube compression. In conventional electromagnetic tube expansion process, the electromagnetic force generated by helix coil system is mainly in the radial direction. And then the wall thickness and the strength of the tube are reduced with the increasing of the radius during the workpiece deformed. As a result, it is difficult to meet the requirement of modern industry for high strength and performance parts.

Figure 8.

Coil system. (a) conventional electromagnetic tube expansion, (b) electromagnetic tube expansion with axial compression.

In order to solve this problem, electromagnetic tube expansion with axial compression is proposed by Qiu et al. Figure 8 shows the structure of coil system in this method. Firstly, the axial and the radial magnetic flux density are generated in the workpiece region by the coil system. Secondly, the radial electromagnetic force is generated by the interaction between the eddy current and the axial magnetic flux density, and the axial electromagnetic force is simultaneously generated by the interaction between the eddy current and the radial magnetic flux density. Finally, the radial electromagnetic force expands the workpiece in the radial direction, while the axial electromagnetic force compresses the workpiece in the axial direction. In this method, the reduction of wall thickness of the workpiece can be effectively decreased and the workpiece deformation performance is improved due to the axial compression.

Figure 9.

Axial electromagnetic force and thickness of the deformed tube. (a) force, (b) thickness.

Figure 9 shows the axial electromagnetic force and the thickness of the tube when using conventional electromagnetic tube expansion and electromagnetic tube expansion with axial compression respectively. The workpiece is AA1060 tube with a diameter of 100 mm and a wall thickness of 2 mm. a helix coil system with inner radius, outer radius, and height of 45 mm, 48 mm, 20 mm respectively is used to expand the workpiece, while another coil system with inner radius, outer radius, and height of 46 mm, 52 mm, 15 mm respectively is used to generate the axial electromagnetic force for axial compression. Under the same expansion depth, it is observed that the axial electromagnetic force generated by electromagnetic tube expansion with axial compression is 6.747 times of that generated by the conventional electromagnetic tube expansion. Furthermore, because of the increase of the axial electromagnetic force, the material flow property is increased in the axial direction, and then the reduction of wall thickness is reduced from 15.05% to 9.65%.

6. Conclusion

Electromagnetic incremental forming, space-time-controlled multi-stage pulsed magnetic field forming, and electromagnetic tube expansion with axial compression have been discussed in this paper. In general, each new method can solve some problems in conventional EMF process, and promote EMF for development. However, some key technical issues in EMF should be solved for achieving industrialized application. One issue is how to design the corresponding coil system according to the specific forming requirements. Another one is how to solve the temperature problem in the coil system caused by the large current. EMF should been widely used in light alloy forming in the future.

Footnotes

Acknowledgments

This work is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (51507092, 51707104) and State Key Laboratory of Advanced Electromagnetic Engineering and Technology (Huazhong University of Science and Technology), and sponsored by Research Fund for Excellent Dissertation of China Three Gorges University (2018SSPY060). The authors thank Bairong Song from School of Foreign Languages, China Three Gorges University for her language translating work and Alan Treworgy from Lewiston, Maine, USA, for his language revision advice.

References

Thibaudeau

and Kinsey

B.L.

, Analytical Design and Experimental Validation of Uniform Pressure Actuator for Electromagnetic Forming and Welding, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 215 (2015), 251–263.

Vivek

Kim

K.H.

and Daehn

G.S.

, Simulation and Instrumentation of Electromagnetic Compression of Steel Tubes, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 211 (2011), 840–850.

Kim

Noh

H.G.

Song

W.J.

and Kang

B.S.

, Analysis of electromagnetic forming process using sequential electromagnetic-structural coupling simulation, International Journal of Applied Electromagnetics & Mechanics 49(2) (2015), 263–278.

Chu

Y.Y.

Lee

R.S.

Psyk

and Tekkaya

A.E.

, Determination of the Flow Curve at High Strain Rates Using Electromagnetic Punch Stretching, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 212 (2012), 1314–1323.

Huang

L.T.

Han

X.T.

Chen

Niu

Y.H.

Lai

Z.P.

Cao

Q.L.

Zhou

Z.Y.

and Li

, Effect of electromagnetic ring expansion on the mechanical property of A5083 aluminum alloy, IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity 24(3) (2014), 7100104.

Kamal

Shang

Cheng

Hatkevich

and Daehn

G.S.

, Agile Manufacturing of a Micro-embossed Case by a Two-step Electromagnetic Forming Process, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 190 (2007), 41–50.

You

J.S.

Kuo

C.L.

and Hwang

S.F.

, Temperature effect on electromagnetic forming process by finite element analysis, International Journal of Applied Electromagnetics & Mechanics 35(1) (2011), 25–37.

C.H.

and Jung

H.K.

, Numerical computation of inductance of complex coil systems, International Journal of Applied Electromagnetics & Mechanics 29(1) (2009), 15–23.

Cao

Q.L.

Han

X.T.

Lai

Z.P.

Xiong

Zhang

Chen

Xiao

H.X.

and Li

, Analysis and reduction of coil temperature rise in electromagnetic forming, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 225 (2015), 185–194.

10.

Psyk

Risch

Kinsey

B.L.

Tekkaya

A.E.

and Kleiner

, Electromagnetic Forming – A Review, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 211 (2011), 787–829.

11.

Woodward

Weddeling

Daehn

Psyk

Carson

and Tekkaya

A.E.

, Production of Low-volume Aviation Components Using Disposable Electromagnetic Actuators, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 211 (2011), 886–895.

12.

Qiu

Han

X.T.

Peng

Ding

H.F.

Xiong

Zhou

Z.Y.

Jiang

C.X.

Y.L.

and Li

, Design and Experiments of a High Field Electromagnetic Forming System, IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity 22(3) (2012), 3700504.

13.

Cao

Q.L.

Han

X.T.

Lai

Z.P.

Zhang

Zhou

Z.Y.

Qiu

and Li

, Effects of Current Frequency on Electromagnetic Sheet Metal Forming Process, IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity 24(3) (2014), 3700104.

14.

Kamal

, A Uniform Pressure Electromagnetic Actuator for Forming Flat Sheets, Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering 129 (2007), 369–379.

15.

Otin

Mendez

and Fruitos

, A frequency domain approach for computing the Lorentz force in electromagnetic metal forming, International Journal of Applied Electromagnetics & Mechanics 46(1) (2014), 125–142.

16.

F.Q.

Fang

Zhu

J.H.

and Li

J.J.

, Study on the homogeneity of deformation under electromagnetic expansion of metal tube, International Journal of Applied Electromagnetics & Mechanics 42(1) (2013), 13–25.

17.

Qiu

Y.J.

Yang

Y.Q.

Nie

X.P.

Xiao

Ning

Wang

F.Z.

and Cao

, Analysis of Electromagnetic Force and Experiments in Electromagnetic Forming with Local Loading, International Journal of Applied Electromagnetics & Mechanics (4) (2018), 1–9.

18.

Qiu

Y.J.

Xiong

Deng

C.Z.

Cao

Q.L.

Han

X.T.

and Li

, Analysis of Electromagnetic Force and Deformation Behavior in Electromagnetic Tube Expansion with Concave Coil Based on Finite Element Method, IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity 28(3) (2018), 1–5.

19.

Cui

X.H.

J.H.

J.J.

Xiao

X.T.

Zhou

and Fang

J.X.

, Large-scale Sheet Deformation Process by Electromagnetic Incremental Forming Combined with Stretch Forming, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 237 (2016), 139–154.

20.

Cui

X.H.

J.H.

J.J.

Zhao

Zhu

Huang

Z.W.

and Zhong

, Electromagnetic Incremental Forming (EMIF): A Novel Aluminum Alloy Sheet and Tube Forming Technology, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 214 (2014), 409–427.

21.

Han

X.T.

Peng

Ding

H.F.

Ding

T.H.

Qiu

Zhou

Z.Y.

and Xiong

, Space-Time-Controlled Multi-Stage Pulsed Magnetic Field Forming and Manufacturing Technology, presented at the 5th High Speed Forming, Dortmund, Germany, April 24–26, 2012.

22.

Lai

Z.P.

Cao

Q.L.

Zhang

Han

X.T.

Zhou

Z.Y.

Xiong

Zhang

Chen

and Li

, Radial Lorentz Force Augmented Deep Drawing for Large Drawing Ratio Using a Novel Dual-coil Electromagnetic Forming System, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 222 (2015), 13–20.

23.

Lai

Z.P.

Cao

Q.L.

Han

X.T.

Huang

Y.J.

Deng

F.X.

Chen

and Li

, Investigation on Plastic Deformation Behavior of Sheet Workpiece During Radial Lorentz Force Augmented Deep Drawing Process, Journal of Materials Processing Technology 245 (2017), 193–206.