In this paper I explore the writings of Pierre Nora on lieux de mémoire (realms of memory). Nora's work is a standard reference in geographical writings on memory, yet there are various assumptions in his work that often go unchallenged. An investigation of the concept of nostalgia allows certain levels of yearning to be made clear in Nora's writings. A melancholic nostalgia for ‘real environments of memory’ and for the unifying power of the nation-state pervades this work. However, Nora hints at the possibility for the survival of memory in the body, and for its defence through the mobilisation of counterhistorical narratives. I conclude through using interdisciplinary theories on embodied memory and sites of countermemory to expand the range of spaces in which the memories of a nation might be constructed, contained, and contested.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AgeronC-R, 1984, L'exposition coloniale de 1931, mythe républicain ou mythe impérial?” [The colonial exhibition of 1931, republican myth or imperial myth?], in Les Lieux de Mémoire, Volume 1: La République Ed. NoraP (Gallimard, Paris) pp 561–591
2.
AntzeP, 2003, “The other inside: memory as metaphor in psychoanalysis”, in Regimes of Memory Eds HodgkinKRadstoneS (Routledge, London) pp 96–113
3.
AntzePLambekM, 1996, “Preface”, in Tense Pasts: Cultural Essays in Trauma and Memory Eds AntzePLambekM (Routledge, London) pp i–xx
4.
BehdadA, 1994Belated Travellers: Orientalism in the Age of Colonial Dissolution (Cork University Press, Cork)
5.
BellD, 1997, “Paris blues”The New Republic 1 September, 32–36
6.
BennettT, 2003, “Stored virtue: memory, body and the evolutionary museum”, in Regimes of Memory Eds HodgkinKRadstoneS (Routledge, London) pp 40–52
7.
BluntA, 2003, “Collective memory and productive nostalgia: Anglo-Indian homemaking at McCluskieganj”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space21717–738
8.
BodnarJ, 2000, “Pierre Nora, national memory, and democracy: a review”Journal of American History87951–963
9.
BoyarinJ, 1994, Space, time and the politics of memory”, in Remapping Memory: The Politics of Timespace Ed. BoyarinJ (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN) pp 1–26
10.
BoymS, 2001The Future of Nostalgia (Basic Books, New York)
11.
BreuillyJ, 2003, “The “place of memory””History88526–529
12.
ButlerJ, 1993Bodies That Matter: On the Discursive Limits of ‘Sex’ (Routledge, London)
13.
ButlerJ, 2003, “Afterword: after loss, what then?”, in Loss: The Politics of Mourning Eds EngD LKazanjianD (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA) pp 467–470
14.
CarrierP, 2000, Places, politics and the archiving of contemporary memory in Pierre Nora's Les Lieux de Mémoire”, in Memory and Methodology Ed. RadstoneS (Berg, Oxford) pp 37–57
15.
CharlesworthA, 1994, “Contesting places of memory: the case of Auschwitz”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space12579–593
16.
ChaseMShawC, 1989, “The dimensions of nostalgia”, in The Imagined Past: History and Nostalgia Eds ChaseMShawC (Manchester University Press, Manchester) pp 1–17
17.
ConnertonP, 1989How Societies Remember (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
18.
CrangMTravlouP S, 2001, “The city and topologies of memory”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space19161–177
DavisF, 1979Yearning for Yesterday: A Sociology of Nostalgia (Macmillan, New York)
21.
de CerteauM, 1985, Practices of space”, in On Signs Ed. BlonskeyM (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 122–145
22.
EagletonT, 1981Walter Benjamin: Towards a Reactionary Criticism (Verso, London)
23.
EdkinsJ, 2003Trauma and the Memory of Politics (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
24.
EldenS, 2001Mapping the Present: Heidegger, Foucault and the Project of Spatial History (Continuum, London)
25.
EngD LKazanjianD, 2003, “Introduction: mourning remains”, in Loss: The Politics of Mourning Eds EngD LKazanjianD (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA) pp 1–20
26.
EnglundS, 1992, “The ghost of the nation past”Journal of Modern History64299–320
27.
FooteK, 1997Shadowed Ground: America's Landscapes of Violence and Tragedy (University of Texas Press, Austin, TX)
28.
ForestBJohnsonJ, 2002, “Unravelling the threads of history: 4. Soviet-era monuments and post-Soviet national identity in Moscow”Annals of the Association of American Geographers92524–547
29.
FoucaultM, 1977, Nietzsche, genealogy, history”, in Language, Counter-memory, Practice: Selected Essays and Interviews by Michel Foucault Ed. BouchardD F (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY) pp 139–164
30.
FoucaultM, 1980Power / Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 1972–1977 (Harvester Wheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
31.
FoucaultM, 2001 [1982], “The subject and power”, in Essential Works of Foucault, 1954–1984: Powervolume 3, Ed. FaubionJ D (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx) pp 326–349
GrossD, 1990, “Critical synthesis on urban knowledge: remembering and forgetting in the modern city”Social Epistemology43–22
38.
GrossD, 2000Lost Time: On Remembering and Forgetting in Late Modern Culture (University of Massachusetts Press, Amherst, MA)
39.
HalbwachsM, 1992On Collective Memory (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)
40.
HeffernanM, 1995, “For ever England: the western front and the politics of remembrance in Britain”Ecumene2293–323
41.
HirschMSpitzerL, 2003, “‘We would never have come without you’: generations of nostalgia”, in Contested Pasts: The Politics of Memory Eds HodgkinKRadstoneS (Routledge, London) pp 79–95
42.
HobsbawmERangerT, 1983Invented Traditions (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
43.
HodgkinKRadstoneS, 2003a, Remembering suffering: trauma and history; introduction”, in Contested Pasts: The Politics of Memory Ed. RadstoneS (Routledge, London) pp 97–107
44.
HodgkinKRadstoneS, 2003b, Introduction: contested pasts”, in Contested Pasts: The Politics of Memory Ed. RadstoneS (Routledge, London) pp 1–21
45.
HutchinsonJSmithA D, 2000, “General introduction”, in Nationalism: Critical Concepts in Political Sciencevolume 1, Eds HutchinsonJSmithA D (Routledge, London) pp xxv–xlii
46.
HuttonP H, 1993History as an Art of Memory (University Press of New England, Hanover, NH)
47.
HuyssenA, 1995Twilight Memories: Marking Times in a Culture of Amnesia (Routledge, New York)
48.
HuyssenA, 2003aPresent Pasts: Urban Palimpsests and the Politics of Memory (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA)
49.
HuyssenA, 2003b, “Memory in the global age: the holocaust”The Germanic Review7886–91
50.
JenkinsK, 1997The Postmodern History Reader (Routledge, London)
51.
JohnsonN, 1995, “Cast in stone: monuments, geography, and nationalism”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1351–65
52.
JohnsonN, 1999, “The spectacle of memory: Ireland's remembrance of the Great War, 1919”Journal of Historical Geography2536–56
53.
JohnsonN, 2004, “Public memory”, in A Companion to Cultural Geography Eds JohnsonNDuncanJScheinR (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 316–327
54.
KleinK L, 2000, “On the emergence of memory in historical discourse (historiography, history, Jews, holocaust, “after-Auschwitz”)”Representations69127–150
55.
KosharR, 2003, “German sites of memory, volume 1–3”Central European History36435–445
56.
KritzmanL D, 1996a, Foreword: in remembrance of things French”, in Realms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, Volume 1: Conflicts and Divisions Ed. KritzmanL D (Columbia University Press, New York) pp ix–xiv
57.
KritzmanL D (Ed.), 1996bRealms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, Volume 1: Conflicts and Divisions (Columbia University Press, New York)
58.
KritzmanL D (Ed.), 1996cRealms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, Volume 2: Traditions (Columbia University Press, New York)
59.
KritzmanL D (Ed.), 1996dRealms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, Volume 3: Symbols (Columbia University Press, New York)
LandzeliusM, 2003, “Commemorative dis(re)membering: erasing heritage, spatializing disinheritance?”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space21195–221
62.
LandzeliusM, 2004, “The body”, in Companion to Cultural Geography Eds DuncanJJohnsonNScheinR (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 279–297
63.
LavisseE, 1900–11Histoire de la France [History of France] (Hachette, Paris)
64.
LeggS, 2003aColonial Governmentality: Spaces of Imperialism and Nationalism in India's New Capital, Delhi 1911–47 unpublished PhD thesis, Department of Geography, University of Cambridge, Cambridge
65.
LeggS, 2003b, “Gendered politics and nationalised homes: women and the anti-colonial struggle in Delhi, 1930–47”Gender, Place and Culture107–27
66.
LeggS, forthcoming, “Sites of countermemory: the refusal to forget and the nationalist struggle in colonial Delhi”Historical Geography
67.
LevyDSznaiderN, 2003Erinnerung im globalen Zeitalter: Der Holocaust [Memory in the global age] (Suhrkamp, Frankfurt)
68.
LewisCPileS, 1996, “Women, body, space: Rio carnival and the politics of performance”Gender, Place and Culture323–41
69.
LowenthalD, 1989, Nostalgia tells it like it wasn't”, in The Imagined Past: History and Nostalgia Ed. ChaseMShawC (Manchester University Press, Manchester) pp 18–32
70.
LowenthalD, 1993, “Memory and oblivion”Museum Management and Curatorship12171–182
71.
MohanramR, 1999Black Body: Women, Colonialism and Space (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
72.
NastHPileS (Eds), 1998Places Through the Body (Routledge, London)
73.
NoraP, 1984aLes Lieux de Mémoire, Volume 1: La République [Realms of memory, volume 1: the republic] (Gallimard, Paris)
74.
NoraP, 1984b, De la république à la nation” [Republic to the nation], in La République Ed. NoraP (Gallimard, Paris) pp 651–659
75.
NoraP, 1986Les Lieux de Mémoire, Volume 2: La Nation [Realms of memory, volume 2: the nation] (Gallimard, Paris)
76.
NoraP, 1989, “Between memory and history: les lieux de mémoire”Representations267–25
77.
NoraP, 1992aLes Lieux de Mémoire, Volume 3: Les France [Realms of memory, volume 3: France] (Gallimard, Paris)
78.
NoraP, 1992b, Comment écrire l'histoire de France” [How to write the history of France], in Les France Ed. NoraP (Gallimard, Paris) pp 9–32
79.
NoraP, 1996a, Era of commemoration”, in Realms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, Volume 3: Symbols Ed. KritzmanL D (Columbia University Press, New York) pp 609–637
80.
NoraP, 1996b, From lieux de mémoire to realms of memory”, in Realms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, Volume 3: Symbols Ed. KritzmanL D (Columbia University Press, New York) pp xv–xxiv
81.
NoraP, 1996c, Introduction to Realms of Memory volume 2.1”, in Realms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, Volume 2: Traditions Ed. KritzmanL D (New York University Press, New York) pp 1–12
82.
PomianK, 1996, Franks and Gauls”, in Realms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, Volume 3: Symbols Ed. KritzmanL D (Columbia University Press, New York) pp 27–79
83.
PortelliA, 2003, “The massacre at the Fosse Ardeatine: history, myth, ritual, and symbol”, in Contested Pasts: The Politics of Memory Eds HodgkinKRadstoneS (Routledge, London) pp 29–40
84.
RadstoneS, 2000, Working with memory: an introduction”, in Memory and Methodology Ed. RadstoneS (Berg, Oxford) pp 1–22
85.
RenanE, 1990, What is a nation?”, in Nation and Narration Ed. BhabhaH K (Routledge, London) pp 19–20
86.
RobertsonR, 1990, After nostalgia? Wilful nostalgia and the phases of globalization”, in Theories of Modernity and Postmodernity Ed. TurnerB S (Sage, London) pp 45–62
87.
RoseM, 2002, “The seductions of resistance: power, politics, and a performative style of systems”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space20383–400
88.
SaidE, 1978Orientalism (Routledge and Kegan Paul, London)
89.
SamuelR, 1994Theatres of Memory: Volume 1: Past and Present in Contemporary Culture (Verso, London)
90.
SquireL R, 1999, Memory and brain systems”, in From Brains to Consciousness? Essays on the New Sciences of the Mind Ed. RoseS (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx) pp 53–69
91.
StaborinskiJ, 1966, “Idea of nostalgia”Diogenes5481–103
92.
StauthGTurnerB S, 1988, “Nostalgia, postmodernism and the critique of mass culture”Theory, Culture and Society5509–526
93.
StewartS, 1984On Longing: Narratives of the Miniature, the Gigantic, the Souvenir, the Collection (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
94.
TaiH T H, 2001, “Remembered realms: Pierre Nora and French national memory”American Historical Review106906–922
95.
TaitheB, 1999, “Realms of memory: the construction of the French past, volume 1, conflicts and divisions”History of the Human Sciences12123–139
96.
TerdimanR, 1985Discourse/Counter-discourse: The Theory and Practice of Symbolic Resistance in Nineteenth-century France (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY)
97.
TerdimanR, 1993Present Past: Modernity and the Memory Crisis (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY)
98.
TillK E, 2003, “Places of memory”, in A Companion to Political Geography Eds AgnewJMitchellKToalG (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 289–301
99.
TillK E, 2005The New Berlin: Memory, Politics, Place (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN)
100.
TobiaB, 1996, Urban space and monuments in the “nationalization of the masses””, in Nationalism in Europe, 1815 to the Present Ed. WoolfS (Routledge, London) pp 171–191
101.
TonniesF, 2001Community and Civil Society Ed. HarrisJ (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge); first published in 1887
102.
TurnerB S, 1987, “A note on nostalgia”Theory, Culture and Society4147–156
103.
VronenS, 1986, “Maurice Halbwachs and the concept of nostalgia”, in Knowledge and Society: Studies in Sociology of Culture Past and Presentvolume 6, Eds KuklickHLongE (JAI Press, Greenwich, CT) pp 55–66
104.
WerbnerR, 1998, Smoke from the barrel of a gun: postwars of the dead, memory and reinscription in Zimbabwe”, in Memory and the Postcolony: African Anthropology and the Critique of Power Ed. WerbnerR (Zed Books, London) pp 71–99
105.
WheelanY, 2002, “The construction of destruction of a colonial landscape: monuments to British monarchs in Dublin before and after independence”Journal of Historical Geography28508–533
106.
WheelanY, 2003Reinventing Modern Dublin: Streetscape, Iconography and the Politics of Identity (University College Dublin Press, Dublin)
107.
WinterJSivanE, 1999, “Introduction”, in War and Remembrance in the Twentieth Century Eds WinterJSivanE (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 1–39
108.
WithersC, 1996, “Place, memory, monument: memorialising the past in contemporary Highland Scotland”Ecumene3325–344
109.
WolfE, 1982Europe and the People without History (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
110.
WoodN, 1994, “Memory's remains: Les Lieux de Mémoire”Memory and History1123–149
111.
YatesF, 1966The Art of Memory (Routledge and Kegan Paul, London)
112.
YerushalmiY H, 1982Zakhor: Jewish History and Jewish Memory (University of Washington Press, Seattle, WA)
113.
YoungJ, 1993The Texture of Memory: Holocaust Memorials and Meaning (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
