In the context of approaches to understanding the European Union (EU) and ‘critical geopolitics’ which traces the construction of geopolitical narratives, the author writes about the imaginations of European society and space as harmonised and networked which are associated with visions of governance for ‘an ever closer union’. This is done through a critical examination of the European Commission's project of sponsoring cross-border cooperation. Drawing on a case study from the Portuguese — Spanish frontier, he examines contradictions that have arisen and are mediated through an unresolved dispute concerning the demarcation of a short section of what is the longest, poorest (in terms of material underdevelopment), and oldest (in terms of relative stability) border between two EU member states. Focusing on the EU-funded (re)construction of a ruined bridge across the border, he examines the way in which the boundary dispute (and attendant Portuguese irredentism) has become enfolded within and disrupts the strategic visions of the EU Working with a mixture of historical and contemporary documents, media accounts, archival records, and interviews relating to this case study, the author reflects on and elaborates broader understandings of the spatiality of power in the EU.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ADENEX, undated, “ADENEX denuncia graves ilegalidades en el proyecto de Alqueva”, Asociación para la Defensa de la Naturaleza y los Recursos de Extremadura, Calle Cuba 27, Mérida E-06800
2.
AndersonJ, 1996, “The shifting stage of politics: New medieval and postmodern territorialities?”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space14133–153
3.
AndricI, 1977The Bridge on the Drina (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL), first published in 1945 as Na Drini Cuprija (Prosveta, Beograd)
4.
AnzaldúaG, 1987Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza (Spinsers/Aunt Lane Books, San Francisco)
ArocaJ L, 1995a, “La Gran presa portuguesa de Alqueva inundaría puente Ajuda en Olivenza”Hoy 25 June, page 3
7.
ArocaJ L, 1995b, “Primero la presa, y luego lo demás”Hoy 25 June, page 3
8.
ArocaJ L, 1998, “Extremadura solicita la constructión de tres nuevos puentes con Portugal”Hoy 15 October
9.
AtkinsonW C, 1960A History of Spain and Portugal (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
10.
BarreirosBaptista J, 1961, “Delimitação da Fronteira Luso-Espanhola”Separata d' “O Distrito de Braga”1 Volume, Fascículos I e II
11.
BarreraL, 1994, “El veto Luso al puente Ajuda saca viejas reivindicaciones”Extremadura 5 June
12.
BarryA, 1993, “The European network”New Formations2926–37
13.
BarryA, 1996, “The European Community and European government: Harmonization, mobility and space”Economy and Society22314–326
14.
BeneytoJ M, 1999Tragedia y razón: Europa en elpensamiento español del siglo XX (Taurus, Madrid)
15.
BerdahlD, 1999Where the World Ended: Re-unification and Identity in the German Borderland (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
16.
BirdJ, 1956, “Scale in regional study illustrated by brief comparisons between the western peninsulas of England and France”Geography4125–38
17.
BlackS, 1975, “Olivenza: An Iberian Alsace/Lorraine”The Americas35527–537
18.
Boletim do Grupo dos Amigos de Olivença1953, “A ponte de Olivença”, number 12
19.
MaurelBosque J, 1984, “Del INC al IRYDA: Análisis de los resultados obtenidos por la política de colonizatión posterior a la guerra civil”Agricultura y Sociedad32153–286
20.
PoyatoCalvo J, 1988La Guerra de Sucesión (Anaya, Madrid)
21.
Câmara Municipal de Elvas, Secretaria, 1990Ponte da Ajuda, sumula da renunião de 17 Janeiro; copy available in the Biblioteca Municipal, Elvas
22.
CaporasoJ A, 1996, “The European Union and forms of state: Westphalian, regulatory or postmodern?”Journal of Common Market Studies34 (1) 29–52
23.
CarandenellL, 1998, “La Frontera a lo largo de los años”Península6 (October) 57
CEPA, 1992, “Dealing with disparity: European Structural Funds in South West Spain”, Coordinadora Extremeña de Protectión Ambiental The Ecologist22 (3) 91–96
26.
de EstadoConsejo, 1927Al Ministro de Estado, expediante numero 13388, aprobado por el Consejo de Estado 25 de febero 1927; copy available in the Biblioteca Municipal Olivenza, folleto 2/46
27.
TorresCordero J M, 1960Fronteras Hispánicas: Geografia e historia diplomacia y administración (Instituto de Estudios Políticos, Madrid)
28.
CunhaA, 1995, “Exército põe ‘enclave’ a nu”A Capital 27 October, page 18
29.
DalbyS, 1990Creating the Second Cold War: The Discourse of Politics (Pinter, London)
30.
da VeigaE, 1863Gibraltar e Olivença: Apontamentos para a historia da usurpação destas duas praças (A Nação, Lisbon)
31.
DehousseR, 1997, “Regulation by networks in the European Community: The role of European agencies”Journal of European Public Policy4 (2) 246–261
32.
De la TorreH, 1997, “Iberismo”, in Enciclopedia del nacionalismo Ed. de Blas GuerroA (Alianza Editorial, Madrid) pp 327–332
33.
de OhveiraN, 1994, “Estamos a chegar ao fim de Portugal”O Dia 26 February
34.
de Otero-SevillaR, 1994, “Yal oeste, Olivenza”Interviú5–11 December
35.
DerridaJ, 1992The Other Heading. Reflections on Today's Europe (Indiana University Press, Bloomington, IN)
36.
Diario do Sul1997, “Ponte de Ajuda vai ser reconstruída”, 14 January, page 7
DouglassW A, 1998, “A western perspective on an eastern interpretation of where north meets south: Pyrenean borderland cultures”, in Border Identities: Nation and State at International Frontiers Eds WilsonT MDonnanH (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 62–95
39.
DrainM, 1996, “Les conflits pour l'eau autour du Guadiana”Espace Rural36115–130
40.
European Commission, 1999, “Notice to the member states laying down guidelines for a Community Initiative concerning trans-European co-operation intended to encourage harmonious and balanced development of the European territory (INTERREG)”, 12 October; available online at http://inforeigo.cec.eu.intwbdoc/docoffic/official/interreg_en.doc
41.
Extremadura1997, “El Alcalde de Elvas hace votos por que nada obstaculice el puente”, 11 January
42.
Financial Times1969, “Portugal and Spain: A skeleton uncovered in Franco's cupboard”, 10 July
43.
FirminoTRibeiroN, 1995, “Espanha mete água na agenda politíca”Público 13 July, page 16
44.
FreelandA, 1999, “Imagined endings: National catastrophe in the fiction of Eça de Queirós”Portuguese Studies15105–118
45.
GarcíaE M, 1997Estudio sobre el Contrabando de Postguerra en Olivenza y su Área de Influencia (Gabinete de Iniciativas Transfronterizas, Mérida)
46.
GarciaJ, 1999, “Olivenza, tierra deseada”El Pais 12 November
VallveGonzalez J L, 1993, “Clausura”, in Frontera y Desarrollo: El Programma Transfronterizo de España y Portugal Eds GonzálezSánchez FDieguezVHerrândezMartín J T, Instituto de Recursos Naturales y Agrobiologia, Cácares, pp 269–271
49.
HériterA, 1997, “Policy-making by subterfuge: Interest accommodation, innovation and substitute democratic legitimization in Europe, perspectives from distinct policy areas”Journal of European Public Policy4171–189
50.
HixS, 1998, “The study of the European Union II: The ‘new governance’ agenda and its rival”Journal of European Public Policy5 (1) 38–65
51.
HoffmannS, 1966, “Obstinate and obsolete? The fate of the nation state in the case of Western Europe”Daedalus95892–908
52.
HolmanO, 1996Integrating Southern Europe: EC Expansion and the Transnationalization of Spain (Routledge, London)
53.
Hoy1995, “Puentes con Portugal”, 20 February
54.
HylandP, 1996Backwards into the Big World: A Voyage into Portugal (HarperCollins, London)
55.
JúlioC, 1995, “As voltas da diplomacia”Imenso Sul—uma revista do Alentejo21–2
56.
KeatingM, 1998, “Is there a regional level of government in Europe?”, in Regions in Europe Eds Le GalèsPLequesneC (Routledge, London) pp 11–29
57.
KleinR, 1999, “Regional cross-border co-operation in the framework of Interreg”, European Commission DG-XVI paper distributed to delegates at the IV Seminario Internacional sobre Fronteras del Desarrollo y Desarrollo de Fronteras, Olivenza, 16–18 March; copy available from J D Sidaway
58.
LatourB, 1993We Have Never Been Modern (Harvester Wheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
59.
LawJHassardJ (Eds), 1998Actor Network Theory and After (Blackwell, Oxford)
60.
LealJ, 1994a, “El Alcalde de Olivenza presionará para que se fijen los límites fronterizos”Hoy 24 May
61.
LealJ, 1994b, “El Tratado, visto desde el otro lado”Hoy 6 June
62.
LealJ, 1994c, “El Gobierno español no se opone a la solución lusa para el puente de Ajuda”Hoy 8 September
63.
PírizLimpo L A, 1987, “El caso oliventino: Concienca nacional y aculturación en un pueblo del suroeste español”Revista de Estudios Extremeños43729–750
64.
PírizLimpo L A, 1989aOlivenza entre Espaňa y Portugal (Exmo Ayuntamiento de Olivenza, Olivenza)
65.
PírizLimpo L A, 1989b, “El puente-forteleza de Ajuda sobre el Guadiana: Una propesta de investigateón”, Encontros/Encuentros. Revista luso-españala de investigadores en ciencias humanas y sociales3145–166
66.
PírizLimpo L A, 1999, “Olivenza, una espina clavada en el flanco sur de Badajoz”Apuntes para la historia de la ciudad de Badajoz (Junta de Extremadura Consejería de Cultura y Patrimonia, Mérida) pp 139–150
67.
LöfgrenO, 1999, “Crossing borders: The nationalization of anxiety”Ethnologia Scandinavie291–24
68.
LorenzoS, 1995, “Lusos e extremeños celebran la próxima constructión del puente de Cedillo”Hoy 19 February
69.
de BastoMagalhães A, 1923, “A fronteira Hispano—Portuguesa (ensaio de Geografia Política)”O Instituto, Revista Scientífica e Literária (Coimbra)7057–69; 103–117; 211–225
70.
MardonesI G, 1998, “El exceso de ganado pone en grave peligro la supervivencia las dehesas españolas”El País 9 November, page 28
71.
MartínezM, 1997Olivenza y el Tratado de Alcañices (Ayuntamiento de Olivenza, Olivenza)
MarksGHoogheLBlackK, 1996, “European integration from the 1980s. State-centric vs multi-level governance”Journal of Common Market Studies34341–378
74.
MoravcsikA, 1991, “Negotiating the Single European Act: National interests and conventional statecraft in the European Community”International Organisation”45 (1) 19–56
75.
MilwardA S, 1992The European Rescue of the Nation State (Routledge, London)
76.
MurdochJ, 1998, “The spaces of actor-network theory”Geoforum29357–374
77.
NairnT, 1977The Break-up of Britain: Crisis and Neonationalism (New Left Books, London)
78.
NaylonJ, 1966, “The Badajoz Plan. An example of land settlement and regional development in Spain”Erkunde20 (1) 44–60
79.
NaylonJ, 1967, “Irrigation and internal colonization in Spain”The Geographical Journal133178–191
80.
NewtonM TDonaghyP J, 1997Institutions of Modern Spain: A Political and Economic Guide (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
CanteroOrtega N, 1979Política Agraria y Dominación del Espacio. Orígenes, Caracterización Planteada en la España Posterior a la Guerra Civil (Ayuso, Madrid)
PaasiA, 1996Territories, Boundaries and Consciousness: The Changing Geographies of the Finnish—Russian Border (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)
85.
Périz-EmbidF, 1975La Frontera entre los Reinos de Sevilla y Portugal (Exmo Ayuntamiento de Sevilla, Sevilla)
86.
PetersonJ, 1994, “The European Community and policy networks. Policy networks and governance in the European Union: The case of research and development policy”Proceedings of the PSA Conference 1994The Political Science Association, c/o Department of Politics, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne, pages 151–169
87.
PintadoABarrenecheaF, 1972La Raya de Portugal: La frontera del suhdesarrollo (Cuadernos para el diálogo, Madrid)
88.
República Portuguesa, Reino de Espanha, 1998Convençàto-quadro entre a República Portuguese e o Reino de Espanha relativa á melhoria das acessibilidades entre os dois paises (signed in Albufeira, Portugal, 30 November)
89.
RhodesR A W, 1997Understanding Governance. Policy Networks, Governance, Reflexivity and Accountability (Open University Press, Milton Keynes)
90.
RibeiroA, 1935, “Últimas conquistas e defmição territorial”, in História de Portugal vol. II Ed. PeresD (Portucalense Editera, Porto) pp 251–273
91.
Risse-KappenT, 1996, “Exploring the nature of the beast: International relations theory and comparative policy analysis meet the European Union”Journal of Common Market Studies34 (1) 53–80
92.
RodriguezJ, 1998, “La Raya de Portugal: Ríos compartidos”Península668–73
RomasantaA M, 1999, “Olivenza versus Olivença”Extremadura 13 November
95.
RoseNMillerP, 1992, “Political power beyond the state: Problematics of government”British Journal of Sociology43173–205
96.
RuggieJ, 1993, “Territoriality and beyond: Problematizing modernity in international relations”International Organisation41139–174
97.
SahlinsP, 1989Boundaries. The Making of France and Spain in the Pyrenees (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
98.
GarcíaSánchez R MPírizLimpo L A, 1998El Enclave de Olivenza y sus Murallas (1230–1640) (Universidad de Extremadura, Cáceres)
99.
GonzálezSánchez J, 1989, “El regionalismo extremeño”, in España Autonomías Ed. FusiJ P (Espasa-Calpe, Madrid) pp 423–463
100.
ScottJ W, 1999, “European and North American contexts for cross-border regionalism”Regional Studies33605–617
101.
ScottJ W, 2000, “Constructing and subsidising transboundary regionalism”, presented at the conference on Rethinking Boundaries: Geopolitics, identities andsustainability 20–24 February, Panjab University, Chandigarh, India; copy available from SidawayJ D
102.
SerrãoJ V, 1979História de PortugalVol. I (Verbo, Lisboa)
103.
ShoreC, 1997, “Metaphors of Europe: Integration and the politics of language”, in Anthropology and Cultural Studies Eds NugentSShoreC (Pluto, London) pp 126–159
SilvaC N, 1998, “Local finance in Portugal: Recent proposals and consequences for urban management”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy16411–421
106.
SlaterD, 1993, “The geopolitical imagination and the enframing of development theory”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series18419–437
107.
SparkeM, 1998, “From geopolitics to geoeconomics: Transnational state effects in borderlands”Geopolitics3262–98
108.
SwyngedouwE, 1999, “Modernity and hybridity: Nature, ‘regenerracionismo’, and the production of the Spanish waterscape 1890–1930”Annals of the Association of American Geographers89443–465
109.
The Times1966, “Portuguese who fight to win back a town: Spain accused of violating rights”, 21 October, page 9
110.
ThuenT, 1999, “The significance of borders in east european transition”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research23738–750
111.
TinocoA, 1990, “España y Portugal, por primera vez de acuerdo para reconstruir Puente Ajuda”Hoy 22 June
112.
TömmelI, 1998, “Transformation of governance: The European Commission's strategy of producing a ‘Europe of the Regions’”Regional and Federal Studies8 (2) 52–80
113.
Tratado de Limites, 1866Tratado de Limites Entre Portugal e Espanha, assinado em Lisboa aos 29 de Setembro de 1864 e aqui trocadas as ratificações a 19 de Maio de 1866 (Imprensa Nacional, Lisboa)
114.
UriarteM L, 1994La Cordosera: Cultura de Frontera y Fronteras Culturales (Editorial Asamblea de Extremadura, Mérida)
115.
VakilA A, 1996, “Nationalising cultural politics: Representations of the Portuguese ‘Discoveries’ and the rhetoric of identitarianism, 1880 – 1926”, in Nationalism and Nation in the Iberian Peninsula: Competing and Conflicting Identities Eds Mar-MolineroCSmithA (Berg, Leamington Spa, Warwicks) pp 33–52
116.
del RíoValcuende J M, 1998Fronteras, Territorios e Identificaciones Colectivas: Interacción Social, Discursos Políticos y Procesos Identitarios en la Frontera Sur Hispano-Portuguesa (Fundacíon Bias Infante, Sevilla)
117.
WalkerM, 1999, “Taming the dollar”Prospectnumber 37 (January) 22–27
118.
WilliamsR H, 1996European Union Spatial Policy and Planning (Paul Chapman, London)
119.
WilsonT MDonnanH, 1998, “Nation, state and identity at international borders”, in Border Identities: Nation and State at International Frontiers Eds WilsonT MDonnanH (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 1–30
120.
YoungH, 1999, “We must face up to the truth: The EU is an experiment in governance”The Guardian 18 March, page 8
