Recent years have seen efforts to critique the dichotomy of ‘nature’ and ‘society’ in Western thought, and to demonstrate their coconstruction under specific material conditions. As yet, however, little work has uncovered the discourses of animality that lie buried within a social field whose ontological status until recently has been securely ‘human’. In this paper, I show how Western concepts of animality have circulated across the nature border and into a politics of social relations. Concepts of savagery and vulgarity can, in particular, be found within racialised representational systems with whose historicity, I will be suggesting, we can make fresh critical engagements. In much recent work on colonial power formations, ‘othering’ practices have been implicitly conceived within a psychoanalytic frame—one in which the white self's ‘interior beasts’ are anxiously displaced onto an externalised other. Whilst not refuting the efficacy of repression I wish to historicise the workings of a peculiar western model of the Human self, ‘split’ into physical ‘animal’ and cultural ‘human’. This is done both through an extended theoretical account, followed by a microstudy of geographies of savagery and civility in Sydney, Australia.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsCDonovanJ (Eds), 1995Animals and Women: Feminist Theoretical ExplorationsDuke University Press, Durham, NC)
2.
AndersonK, 1991Vancouver's Chinatown: Racial Discourse in Canada, 1875–1980McGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal)
3.
AndersonK, 1993, “Place narratives and the origins of the Aboriginal settlement in inner Sydney, 1972–73”Journal of Historical Geography19314–335
4.
AndersonK, 1995, “Culture and nature at the Adelaide Zoo: at the frontiers of ‘human’ geography”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series20275–294
5.
AndersonK, 1997, “A walk on the wild side: a critical geography of domestication”Progress in Human Geography21463–485
6.
AndersonK, 1998, “Science and the Savage: the Linnean Society of New South Wales, 1874–1900”Ecumene5125–143
7.
AndersonK, 1999, “Reflections on Redfern”, in Australian Cultural Geographies Ed. StratfordE (Oxford University Press, Melbourne) pp 67–85
8.
ArlukeASandersC, 1996Regarding Animals: Animals, Culture and SocietyTemple University Press, Philadelphia, PA)
9.
BakerS, 1993Picturing the Beast: Animals, Identity and RepresentationManchester University Press, Manchester)
10.
BalmeD (Ed.), 1991Aristotle, History of Animals, Books VII-XHarvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
11.
BellearR, 1976The Black Housing BookAmber Press, Sydney)
12.
BinghamN, 1996, “Objections: from technological determinism towards geographies of technology”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space14635–658
13.
BirkeLHubbardR (Eds), 1995Reinventing Biology: Respect for Life and Creation of KnowledgeIndiana University Press, Bloomington, IN)
14.
BlundellS, 1986The Origins of Civilization in Greek and Roman ThoughtCroom Helm, London)
15.
BrantlingerP, 1986, “Victorians and Africans: the genealogy of the myth of the Dark Continent”, in Race, Writing, and Difference Ed. GatesH LJr (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL) pp 185–222
16.
BraunBCastreeN (Eds), 1998Remaking Reality: Nature at the MillenniumRoutledge, London)
17.
ClarkS, 1982The Nature of the Beast: Are Animals Moral?Oxford University Press, Oxford)
18.
CockburnC, 1996, “A short, meat-oriented history of the world from Eden to the Mattole”New Left Review21516–42
19.
CunneenC, 1990Aboriginal-Police Relations in Redfern: With Special Reference to the ‘Police Raid’ of 8 February 1990Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission, 133 Castlereagh Street, Sydney, NSW 2000
20.
DAA, 1972–73, miscellaneous Redfern files, Department of Aboriginal Affairs, Woden, Canberra, ACT 2606
21.
DamasioA, 1994Descarte's Error: Emotion, Reason and Human BrainPutnams, New York)
22.
DarwinC, 1968On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or the Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life first published in 1859Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
23.
DavidsonA, 1991, “The horror of monsters”, in The Boundaries of Humanity: Humans, Animals, Machines Eds SheehanJSosnaM (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA) pp 36–67
24.
DemerittD, 1994, “The nature of metaphors in cultural geography and environmental history”Progress in Human Geography18163–185
25.
DudleyENovakM (Eds), 1972The Wild Man Within: An Image in Western Thought from the Renaissance to RomanticismUniversity of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, PA)
26.
DunayerJ, 1995, “Sexist words, speciesist roots”, in Animals and Women: Feminist Theoretical Explorations Eds AdamsCDonovanJ (Duke University Press, Durham, NC) pp 11–21
27.
EdelsteinL, 1967The Idea of Progress in Classical AntiquityJohns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
28.
EliasN, 1982The Civilising Process: State Formation and CivilisationBasil Blackwell, Oxford)
29.
EvansE, 1987The Criminal Prosecution and Capital Punishment of Animals: The Lost History of Europe's Animal Trials first published in 1906Faber and Faber, London)
30.
EzeE (Ed.), 1997Race and the EnlightenmentBlackwell, Oxford)
31.
FanonF, 1967Black Skins, White MasksGrove, New York)
32.
FoucaultM, 1981The History of Sexuality, Volume 1Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
33.
FredricksonG, 1981White SupremacyOxford University Press, New York)
34.
FreudS, 1961Civilisation and its DiscontentsW W Norton, New York)
35.
FriedmanJ, 1981The Monstrous Races in Medieval Art and ThoughtHarvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
36.
GarnseyP, 1996Ideas of Slavery from Aristotle to AugustineCambridge University Press, Cambridge)
37.
GatesP, 1996Animal SenseCambridge University Press, Cambridge)
38.
GerberJ, 1997, “Beyond dualism: the social construction of nature and the natural and social construction of human beings”Progress in Human Geography211–17
39.
GlackenC, 1967Traces on the Rhodian ShoreUniversity of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
40.
GlendinningS, 1996, “Heidegger and the question of animality”International Journal of Philosophical Studies467–86
41.
GoldbergT, 1995Racist Culture: Philosophy and the Politics of MeaningBlackwell, Oxford)
42.
GoldieT, 1989Fear and Temptation: The Image of the Indigene in Canadian, Australian and New Zealand LiteraturesMcGill-Queen's University Press, Montreal)
43.
GreensladeW, 1994Degeneration, Culture and the Novel 1880–1940Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
44.
HamJ, 1997, “Taming the beast: animality in Wedekind and Nietzsche”, in Animal Acts: Configuring the Human in Western History Eds HamJSeniorM (Routledge, London) pp 145–164
45.
HamJSeniorM (Eds), 1997Animal Acts: Configuring the Human in Western HistoryRoutledge, London)
46.
HamlinW, 1995The Image of America in Montaigne, Spenser and ShakespeareSt Martin's Press, New York)
47.
HansenP, 1997The TruthIpswich, Queensland)
48.
HarawayD, 1992Primate VisionsVerso, London)
49.
HawkinsM, 1997Social Darwinism in European and American Thought, 1860–1945Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
50.
Hon. Gordon Bryant papers, Commonwealth Record Series M350, M474, Australian Archives, Victoria
51.
HulliungM, 1994The Autocritique of Enlightenment: Rousseau and the PhilosophiesHarvard University Press, Cambridge, MA)
52.
IngoldT, 1992, “Editorial”Man27693–696
53.
IngoldT, 1994, “Humanity and animality”, in Companion Encyclopedia of Anthropology: Humanity, Culture and Social Life Ed. IngoldT (Routledge, London) pp 14–32
54.
JacobyK, 1994, “Slaves by nature? Domestic animals and human slaves”Slavery and Abolition1589–99
55.
JordanW, 1968White over Black: American Attitudes Toward the Negro, 1550–1812Penguin Books, New York)
56.
KristevaJ, 1982Powers of HorrorColumbia University Press, New York)
57.
LloydG, 1984The Man of ReasonMethuen, London)
58.
McClintockA, 1995Imperial Leather: Race, Gender and Sexuality in the Colonial ContestRoutledge, London)
59.
MalchowH, 1993, “Frankenstein's monster and images of race in nineteenth century Britain”Past and Present13990–130
60.
ManningASerpellJ (Eds), 1994Animals and Human Society: Changing PerspectivesRoutledge, London)
61.
MasonJ, 1979The Indispensable Rousseau excerpts from Discourse on the Origins of Inequality (1754) by RousseauJ-J (Quartet Books, London)
62.
MassonJMcCarthyS, 1996When Elephants Weep: The Emotional Lives of AnimalsRandom House, New York)
63.
MidgelyM, 1979Beast and Man: The Roots of Human NatureHarvester Press, Hemel Hempstead, Herts)
64.
MidgelyM, 1984Animals and Why They MatterGeorgia University Press, Georgia)
65.
MorganL, 1877Ancient Society, or Researchers in the Lines of Human Progress from Savagery to Barbarism to CivilisationCharles H Kerr, Chicago, IL)
66.
MurphyT, 1970–75, Personal papers and Redfern records of Council of the City of South Sydney; granted by Terry Murphy to author and from whom copies are available
67.
NoskeB, 1989Humans and Other Animals: Beyond the Boundaries of AnthropologyPluto Press, London)
68.
OwensE, 1991The City in the Greek and Roman WorldRoutledge, London)
69.
PagdenA, 1982The Fall of Natural Man: The American Indian and the Origins of Comparative EthnologyCambridge University Press, Cambridge)
70.
ParburyN, 1986Survival: A History of Aboriginal Life in New South WalesMinistry of Aboriginal Affairs, Sydney, New South Wales)
71.
PearceR-H, 1988Savagism and Civilisation: A Study of the Indian and the American MindUniversity of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
72.
PhiloC, 1995, “Animals, geography and the city: notes on inclusions and exclusions”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space13655–681
73.
PlumwoodV, 1993Feminism and the Mastery of ScienceRoutledge, London)
74.
ProctorJPincetlS, 1996, “Nature and the reproduction of endangered space: the spotted owl in the Pacific Northwest and southern California”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space14683–708
75.
RitvoH, 1992, “The animal connection”, in The Boundaries of Humanity: Humans, Animals, Machines Eds SheehanJSosnaM (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA) pp 68–84
76.
RosenB, 1969WitchcraftEdward Arnold, London)
77.
SaidE, 1978OrientalismRandom House, New York)
78.
SalisburyJ, 1997, “Human beasts and bestial humans in the middle ages”, in Animal Acts: Configuring the Human in Western History Eds HamJSeniorM (Routledge, London) pp 9–23
79.
SerpellJ, 1996In the Company of Animals: A Study of Human — Animal RelationshipsCambridge University Press, Cambridge)
80.
ShalerN, 1896Domesticated Animals: Their Relation to Man and to his Advancement in CivilisationSmith, Elder, London)
81.
SibleyD, 1995Geographies of ExclusionRoutledge, London)
82.
SibleyD, 1998, “The problematic nature of exclusion”Geoforum29119–122
83.
SorabjiR, 1993Animal Minds and Human Morals: The Origins of the Western DebateCornell University Press, Ithaca, New York)
84.
South Sydney Community Aid, 1970, submission to Commonwealth Office of Aboriginal Affairs, 30 September 1970, unpublished document, in Murphy papers
85.
StolerL, 1995Race and the Education of Desire: Foucault's History of Sexuality and the Colonial Order of ThingsDuke University Press, Durham, NC)
86.
ThomasK, 1983Man and the Natural World: Changing Attitudes in England 1500–1800Allen Lane, London)
87.
ThriftN, 1996Spatial FormationsSage, London)
88.
TogovnickM, 1990Gone Primitive: Savage Intellects, Modern LivesChicago University Press, Chicago, IL)
89.
TrefferyV, 1972, St Vincent's Church, Redfern Street, Redfern, unpublished report, 3 November, in Murphy papers
90.
TrotmanP, 1973, Circumstances in Louis/Caroline Street, Redfern, unpublished report, 23 March, in NSW Office of Aboriginal Affairs, miscellaneous Redfern Files 1972–73
91.
WallM, 1997, “Stereotypical constructions of the Maori ‘race’ in the media”New Zealand Geographer5340–45
92.
WeberM, 1976The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (Charles Scribner's Sons, New York)
93.
WhatmoreSThornsL, 1998, “Wild(er)ness: reconfiguring the geographies of wildlife”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series23435–454
94.
WhiteH, 1972, “The forms of wildness: archaeology of an idea”, in The Wild Man Within: An Image in Western Thought from the Renaissance to Romanticism Eds DudleyENovakM (University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, PA) p 3–38
95.
Willems-BraunB, 1997, “Buried epistemologies: the politics of nature in (post)colonial British Columbia”Annals of the Association of American Geographers873–31
96.
WillisR (Ed.), 1994Signifying Animals: Human Meaning in the Natural WorldRoutledge, London)
97.
WiltonR, 1998, “The constitution of difference: space and psyche in landscapes of exclusion”Geoforum29173–185
98.
WolchJEmelJ (Eds), 1998Animal Geographies: Place, Politics and Identity in the Nature-Culture BorderlandsVerso, London)
