Geographers dealing with religion have pointed to the process of conflict and contestation involved in the production of sacred sites. This paper explores the conflict over a sacred site in the formulation of a minority identity through transformation of the place into a nexus of resistance and collective memory formation. I argue that under hegemonic secularizing states and within the context of ethnonational conflicts minority groups mobilize and articulate a dynamic meaning of sacred sites which allows an elaborate politics of identity. Further, in the context of their national struggle, members of the community emphasize different aspects of the sacred. In the context of the national struggle (and for the duration of the conflict), minority members enhance inclusive nationalistic (Palestinian in this particular case) identity; however, while in a community context they emphasize the religious (Islamic) meaning of the place. Particularly, I examine the dynamic nature of interpreting and constructing the sacred through the analysis of the restoration project of the Hassan Bek mosque by the Arab-Palestinian community of Jaffa, Israel.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AmaraM, 1999, “Identity dilemma of Palestinians in Israel”, in Identity and Education in Germany and Israel Eds HoffmanASchnellIStephenGBrauerGFennP, (Fachverlag für wissenschaftliche Literatur, Hamburg) pp 213–234
2.
AppaduraiA, 1997, “Sovereignty without territoriality: Notes for a postnational geography”, in Geography of Identity Ed. YeagerP, (University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, MI) pp 40–58
3.
AzaryahuM, 2007Tel Aviv: Mythography of City (Syracuse University Press, Syracuse, NY)
4.
AzaryahuMKellermanA, 1999, “Symbolic places of national history and revival: A study in Zionist mythical geography”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series24109–123
5.
BergerP L, 1999, “The desecularization of the world: A global overview”, in The Desecularization of the World: Resurgent Religion and World Politics Ed. BergerP L, (Eerdmans, Washington, DC) pp 1–18
6.
BisharaA, 1993, “On the question of the Arab minority in Israel”Teoria VeBikoret27–20
7.
BourdieuP, 1993, “Effets de lieu”, in La Misère du Monde Ed. BourdieuP, (Seuil, Paris) pp 159–167
8.
BraceCBaileyA RHarveyD C, 2006, “Religion, place and space: A framework for investigating historical geographies of religious identities and communities”Progress in Human Geography3028–43
9.
ButtimerA, 2006, “Afterword: Reflections on geography, religion, and belief systems”Annals of the Association of American Geographers96199–202
10.
CastellsM, 1983The City and the Grassroots (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
11.
ChidesterDLinenthalE T, 1995, “Introduction”, in American Sacred Space Eds ChidesterDLinenthalE T, (Indiana University Press, Bloomington, IN) pp 1–42
12.
ChivallonC, 2001, “Religion as space for the expression of Caribbean identity in the United Kingdom”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space19461–483
13.
DabbaghM M, 1972Biladuna Filastin (Matbuat al-Khukuma, Beirut)
14.
DurkheimE, 1912The Elementary Forms of the Religious Life translated by SwainJ W, (Allen and Unwin, London)
15.
EadeJSallnowM J, 1991, “Introduction”, in Contesting the Sacred: The Anthropology of Christian Pilgrimage Eds EadeJSallnowM J, (Routledge, London) pp 1–29
16.
EliasNScotsonJ L, 1965The Established and the Outsiders: A Sociological Enquiry into Community Problems (Sage, London)
17.
FormanGKedarS, 2004, “From Arab land to ‘Israel Lands’: The legal dispossession of the Palestinians displaced by Israel in the wake of 1948”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space22809–830
18.
GhanemA, 2001The Palestinian-Arab Minority in Israel, 1948–2000: A Political Study (State University of New York Press, Albany, NY)
19.
GolanA, 1995, “The demarcation of Tel Aviv-Jaffa's municipal boundaries following the 1948 war: Political conflicts and spatial outcome”Planning Perspectives10383–395
20.
GolanA, 1999, “Zionism, urbanism, and the 1948 wartime transformation of the Arab urban system in Palestine”Historical Geography27152–166
21.
GolanA, 2001Wartime Spatial Changes: Former Arab Territories Within the State of Israel, 1948–1950 (Ben-Gurion University of the Negev Press, Beer Sheva)
22.
GramsciA, 1971Selections from Prison Notebooks (International Publishers, New York)
23.
HamudaS, 1985Masjid Hassan Bey (Hassan Abu Daw, Bayt Safafa)
24.
HarveyD, 1979, “Monument and myth”Annals of the American Geographers Association69362–381
25.
HarveyD, 1989The Urban Experience (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD)
26.
HarveyD, 2000Spaces of Hope (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
HaynesDParkashG, 1991, “Introduction: The entanglement of power and resistance”, in Contesting Power: Resistance and Everyday Social Relations in South Africa Eds HaynesDParkashG, (Oxford University Press, Delhi) pp 1–22
29.
HechtR D, 1994, “The construction and management of sacred time and space: Sabta Nur in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre”, in Now Here: Space, Time and Modernity Eds FriedlandRBodenD, (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA) pp 181–235
30.
Hervieu-LegerD, 2000Religion as a Chain of Memory translated by LeeS, (Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick, NJ)
31.
HollowayJValinsO, 2002, “Editorial: Placing religion and spirituality in geography”Social and Cultural Geography3 (1) 5–9
32.
IvakhivA, 2006, “Towards a geography of ‘religion’: Mapping the distribution of an unstable signifier”Annals of the Association of American Geographers96169–175
33.
JazeelT, 2005, “‘Nature’, nationhood and the poetics of meaning in Ruhuna (Yala) National Park, Sri Lanka”Cultural Geographies12199–229
34.
KimmerlingB, 1983Zionism and Territory (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
35.
KongL, 1990, “Geography and religion: Trends and prospects”Progress in Human Geography14355–371
36.
KongL, 1993a, “Ideological hegemony and the political symbolism of religious buildings in Singapore”Southern Asian Journal of Social Sciences20 (1) 18–42
37.
KongL, 1993b, “Negotiating conception of sacred space: A case study of religious building in Singapore”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series18342–358
38.
KongL, 2001, “Mapping ‘new’ geographies of religion: Politics and poetics in modernity”Progress in Human Geography25211–233
39.
KupferschmidtU M, 1987The Supreme Muslim Council: Islam under the British Mandate for Palestine (E J Brill, Leiden)
40.
Law-YoneHKallusR, 2001, “The dynamics of ethnic segregation in Israel”, in The Power of Planning. Spaces of Control and Transformation Eds YiftachelOLittleJHedgcockDAlexanderI, (Kluwer, Boston, MA) pp 171–188
41.
LazarH, 1961The Conquest of Jaffa (Shelah, Tel Aviv)
42.
LefebvreH, 1991The Production of Space translated by Nicholson-SmithD, (Blackwell, Oxford)
43.
LeitnerHPeckJSheppardE, (Eds), 2007Contesting Neoliberalism: Urban Frontiers (Guilford Press, New York)
44.
LeVineM, 2005Overthrowing Geography: Jaffa, Tel Aviv, and the Struggle for Palestine 1880–1948 (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
45.
MarcuseP, 1995, “Not chaos but walls: Postmodernism and the partitioned city”, in Postmodern Cities and Space Eds WatsonSGibsonK, (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 187–198
46.
MarwellGOliverP, 1993The Critical Mass in Collective Action (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
47.
MayerR, 1993, “The development of the Islamic movement in Israel”Arabs in Israel32–20
48.
MeirT, 1998The Resurgence of the Moslems in Israel (Center for Arabic Studies, Givat Haviva)
49.
MonterescuD, 2005, “Facing south?: The paradoxes of governmentality in Jaffa 1985–2004”, in Tel Aviv Jaffa Studies Eds MenahemGNachmiasD, (Diyonon Press, Tel Aviv) pp 142–171
50.
MumfordL, 1938The Culture of Cities (Harcourt, Brace and Co, New York)
51.
NaylorSRyanJ R, 2002, “The mosque in the suburb: Negotiating religion and ethnicity in South London”Social and Cultural Geography3 (1) 39–59
52.
NewmanDPaasiA, 1998, “Fences and neighbours in the postmodern world: Boundary narratives in political geography”Progress in Human Geography22186–207
53.
NoraP, 1996Realms of Memory (Columbia University Press, New York)
54.
PileS, 1997, “Introduction: Oppositional, political identities and spaces of resistance”, in Geographies of Resistance Eds PileSKeithM, (Routledge, London) pp 1–32
55.
PoratY, 1974The Emergence of the Palestine-Arab National Movement 1918–1927 (Frank Cass, London)
56.
ProctorJ D, 2006, “Introduction: Theorizing and studying religion”Annals of the Association of American Geographers96165–168
57.
RabinowitzDMonterescuD, forthcoming, “Reconfiguring the ‘mixed towns’: Urban transformations of ethno-national relations in Palestine/Israel”International Journal of Middle Eastern Studies40(2)
58.
RekhessE, 1989, “The Arabs in Israel and the Arabs in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip: Political ties and national identity”Hamizrach Hachdas32165–191
59.
RekhessE, 2002, “The Arabs in Israel: Localization of the national struggle”Israel Studies7 (3) 175–198
60.
RotbardS, 2005White City, Black City (Bavel, Tel Aviv)
61.
SandercockL, 1998Towards Cosmopolis: Planning for the Multicultural Cities and Regions (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)
62.
SchnellI, 1996Perceptions of Israeli Arabs: Territoriality and Identity (Avebury, Aldershot, Hants)
63.
ScottJ C, 1990Domination and the Arts of Resistance: Hidden Transcripts (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
64.
ShavitYBigerG, 2001The History of Tel Aviv: From Neighborhoods to City (1909–1936) (Ramot, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv)
65.
SibleyD, 1995Geographies of Exclusion (Routledge, London)
66.
SibleyD, 1999, “Creating geographies of difference”, in Human Geography Today Eds MasseyDAllenJSarreP, (Polity Press, Cambridge) pp 115–128
67.
StumpR W, 1986, “Introduction: The geography of religion”Journal of Cultural Geography5510–524
68.
TolkowskyS, 1924The Gateway of Palestine: A History of Jaffa (Routledge, London)
69.
TurnerV W, 1974a, “Pilgrimage as a social process”, in Drama, Fields, and Metaphors: Symbolic Actions in Human Society (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY) pp 166–230
70.
TurnerV W, 1974b, “Pilgrimage and communitas”Studia Missionalia23305–327
71.
ValinsO, 2003, “Stubborn identities and the construction of socio-spatial boundaries: Ultra-orthodox Jews living in contemporary Britain”Transaction of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series28158–175
72.
YiftachelO, 1992Planning a Mixed Region in Israel: The Political Geography of Arab–Jewish Relations in the Galilee (Avebury, Aldershot, Hants)
73.
YiftachelOYacobiH, 2003, “Urban ethnocracy: Ethnicity and the production of space in an Israeli ‘mixed city’”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space21673–693
74.
YoungI, 1990, “The ideal of community and the politics of difference”, in Feminism/Postmodernism Ed. NicholsonL J, (Routledge, New York) pp 300–323
75.
ZukinS, 1995The Cultures of Cities (Blackwell, Maiden, MA)
