In this paper I argue that the informal hawala money-transfer networks, which were made to take much of the blame for terrorist financing in the wake of the September 11 attacks, are not ‘underground’ banking systems but are connected to Western banking in a myriad of ways. I argue that negative stereotyping of hawala in press and policy discourses has implicitly constructed Western banking as the normal and legitimate space of international finance and has deflected calls for regulation of Western investment banking. I discuss how hawala is connected to the financial exclusion of migrant workers in the West. In the war on terrorist finance, discourses of hawala have led to the underestimation of the complexity of cutting off terrorist funding, while criminalising remittance networks.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AdamsR H, 1998, “Remittances, investment and rural asset accumulation in Pakistan”Economic Development and Cultural Change47(1) 155–173
2.
AhmedI I, 2000, “Remittances and their economic impact in post-war Somaliland”Disasters24380–389
ArnoldF, 1992, “The contribution of remittances to economic and social development”, in International Migration Systems Eds KritzM MLimL LZlotnikH (Clarendon Press, Oxford) pp 205–220
5.
BariekR, 2001, “Prepared statement of Mr. Rahim Bariek”, Hearing on Hawala and Underground Terrorist Financing Mechanisms, US Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs, 14 November, banking.senate.gov/01_11hrg/111401/bariek.htm
6.
BayhE, 2001, “Opening statement of subcommittee Chairman Evan Bayh (D-IN)”, Hearing on Hawala and Underground Terrorist Financing Mechanisms, US Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs, 14 November, banking.senate.gov/01_11hrg/111401/bayh.htm
BeharR, 2002, “Kidnapped nation: welcome to Pakistan, America's frontline ally in the war on terror”Fortune 29 April, page 84
10.
BierstekerT J, 2002, “Targeting terrorist finances: the new challenges of financial market globalisation”, in Worlds in Collision: Terror and the Future of Global Order Eds BoothKDunneT (Palgrave, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 74–84
11.
BodenD, 2000, “Worlds in action: information, instantaneity and global futures trading”, in The Risk Society and Beyond: Critical Issues for Social Theory Eds AdamBBeckUvan LoonJ (Sage, London) pp 183–197
12.
BushnellD, 2002, “Opening statement of David Bushnell”, Hearing on The Role of the Financial Institutions in Enron's Collapse, US Senate Committee on Governmental Affairs, 23 July, www.senate.gov/∼gov_affairs/072302bushnell.pdf
13.
Business Week2001, “Western Union: where the money is—in small bills”, 26 November, pages 40–41
14.
CampbellD, 2002, “Time is broken: the return of the past in the response to September 11”Theory and Event5(4), www.tnr.com/101501/cottle101501.html
CernyP, 1997, “The search for a paperless world: technology, financial globalisation and policy response”, in Technology, Culture and Competitiveness: Change and the World Economy Eds TalalayMFarrandsCToozeR (Routledge, London) pp 153–166
17.
ChoucriN, 1986, “The hidden economy: a new view of remittances in the Arab World”World Development14697–712
CottleM, 2001, “Hawala v. the war on terrorism: Eastern Union” The New Republic 15 October, www.tnr.com/101501/cottle101501.html, accessed May 2002
22.
CoutinS BMaurerBYngvessonB, 2002, “In the mirror: the legitimation work of globalization”Law and Social Inquiry27801–843
23.
DamK W, 2001, “Hunting down dirty cash: the international coalition must step up its efforts to stem the flow of terrorist funds or risk further attack”Financial Times 12 December
24.
DamK W, 2002, “Prepared statement of the Honorable Kenneth W. Dam”, Hearing on The Financial War on Terrorism and the Administration's Implementation of the Anti-Money Laundering Provisions of the USA Patriot Act, US Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs, 29 January, banking.senate.gov/02_01hrg/012902/dam.htm
HasselströmA, 2000, “‘Can't buy me love’: negotiating ideas of trust, business and friendship in financial markets”, in Ökonomie und Gesellschaft Jahrbuch 16: Facts and Figures: Economic Representations and Practices Eds KalthoffHRottenburgRWagenerH-J (Metropolis Verlag, Marburg) pp 257–275
40.
HenchD, 2002, “Man guilty of running unlicensed ‘hawala’” Portland Press Herald 1 May, page 1A
HerraraJ A, 2002, “Testimony of John A Herrera”, Hearing Entitled The Patriot Act Oversight: Investigating Patterns of Terrorist Financing, House Committee on Financial Services, Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, 12 February, financialservices.house.gov/media/pdf/021202jh.pdf
43.
JonesR C, 1998, “Remittances and inequality: a question of migration stage and geographic scale”Economic Geography74(1) 8–25
44.
JostP, 2001, “Prepared statement of Mr. Patrick Jost”, Hearing on Hawala and Underground Terrorist Financing Mechanisms, US Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs, 14 November, banking.senate.gov/01_11hrg/111401/jost.htm
PalanR, 1998, “Trying to have your cake and eating it: how and why the state system has created offshore”International Studies Quarterly42625–644
57.
PalanR, 1999, “Offshore and the structural enablement of sovereignty”, in Offshore Finance Centres and Tax Havens: The Rise of Global Capital Eds HamptonM PAbbottJ P (Macmillan, London) pp 18–42
ThachukK L, 2002, “Terrorism's financial lifeline: can it be severed?”, Post-9/11 Critical Issues Series number 191, May, Institute for National Strategic Studies, National Defense University, www.ndu.edu/inss/strforum/sf191/sf191.pdf
69.
The Economist2001, “Terrorists and hawala banking: cheap and trusted”, 24 November, page 97
ThriftN, 1994, “On the social and cultural determinants of international financial centres: the case of the City of London”, in Money, Power, Space Eds CorbridgeSMartinRThriftN (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 327–355
72.
ThriftN, 2001, “Elsewhere”, in Capital Eds CummingsNLewandowskaM (Tate Publishing, London) pp 82–105
73.
TurnerMAldenE, 2001, “US decision to close bank ‘will hit Somalis’”Financial Times 9 November
WeberC, 2002, “Flying planes can be dangerous”Millennium31(1) 129–147
76.
WechslerW F, 2001, “Terror's money trail”New York Times 26 September, page A19
77.
WeinerTJohnstonD C, 2001, “A nation challenged: the paper trail; roadblocks cited in efforts to trace Bin Laden's money”New York Times “Special report inside Al Qaeda: trail of terrorist dollars that spans the world: suitcases of cash, informal money transfers, standard banking procedures—al Qaeda used them all to pay the bills of terrorism” Financial Times 29 November
78.
World Bank, 2003, “Global development finance 2003—striving for stability in development finance”, 2 April, www.worldbank.org/prospects/gdf2003/
79.
YousefT M, 2001, “Prepared statement of Dr. Tarik M. Yousef”, Hearing on Hawala and Underground Terrorist Financing Mechanisms, US Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs, 14 November, banking.senate.gov/01_11hrg/111401/yousef.htm
