In this paper we examine the Israeli government's use of law to institutionalize the dispossession of Palestinian Arabs displaced by the 1948 war and trace the legal transformation of their land during the formative years of Israel's land regime (1948–60). This legal transformation facilitated the expropriation and reallocation of formerly Arab land to primarily Jewish hands and was therefore a central component of the legal reordering of space within Israel after 1948. Based on close examination of Israeli legislation, archival documents, Knesset proceedings, and other sources we delineate a 12-year legislative process consisting of four phases, each concluding with the enactment of major legislation. The process was led by senior and second-tier Israeli officials, and the result was the construction of a new Israeli legal geography. The culmination of the process was the integration of appropriated Arab land into the country's new system of Jewish-Israeli ‘national land’ known as ‘Israel Lands’.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abu-SittaS, 2001, “The right of return: Sacred, legal and possible”, in Palestinian Refugees: The Right of Return Ed. AruriN (Pluto Press, London) pp 195–207.
2.
Agricultural Center, 1948, Bloc Committee minutes from 12 August, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (97) 2185-gim/38 (in Hebrew).
3.
AkaviaA, 1953, “Administration of land under state supervision”, Internal Development Authority memo, 8 January, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (43) 5480-gim/13 (in Hebrew).
4.
AloniR, 1955, “Report on the Implementation of the Land Acquisition Law as of 1 December 1954”, 13 January, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (74) 2868-gim/0/90 (in Hebrew).
5.
AruriN (Ed.), 2001Palestinian Refugees: The Right of ReturnPluto Press, London).
6.
BaumlY, 2002The Attitude of the Israeli Establishment to the Arabs in Israel unpublished PhD thesis, Department of Middle Eastern History, University of Haifa, Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
Ben-GurionD, no date Journal of David Ben-GurionBen-Gurion Archive, Sde-Boker, Israel (in Hebrew).
9.
Ben-GurionD, 1957, Letter from Prime Minister to Eshkol, Gvati, Weitz, Luz, Naftali and Sapir, 31 July, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (43) 5562-gim/7430 (in Hebrew).
BisharatG, 1994, “Land, law and legitimacy in Israel and the occupied territories”The American University Law Review43467–561.
12.
BlomleyN, 2000, “‘Acts’, ‘deeds’ and the violence of property”Historical Geography2886–107.
13.
BlomleyNBakanJ, 1992, “Spacing out: Towards a critical geography of law”Osgoode Hall Law Journal30661–664.
14.
BlomleyNDelaneyDFordR, 2001, “Preface: Where is law?”, in The Legal Geographies Reader Eds BlomelyNDelaneyDFordR (Blackwell, Oxford) pp xiii–xxii.
15.
BlumA, 1951, Letter from Chief Assessor to the Justice Minister, 20 February, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2401-htz/21 II (in Hebrew).
16.
BuntonM, 1999, “Inventing the status quo: Ottoman land-law during the Palestine Mandate, 1917–1936”The International History Review21(1) 28–56.
17.
ButlinR, 1993Historical Geography: Through the Gates of Space and TimeArnold, London).
18.
CohenH, 2000The Present Absentees: The Palestinian Refugees in Israel since 1948Institute for Israeli Arab Studies, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew).
19.
CohenM, 1993, “Property and sovereignty”, in American Legal Realism Eds FisherWHorowitzMReedT (Oxford University Press, New York) pp 109–114; first published in 1927.
20.
DA, 1958, Agreement for Compensation between the Development Authority and Former Owners of Land Expropriated by the Absentee Property Law, Development Authority, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (33) Sh'ab/Settlement Case 6, 17 September.
21.
DaninEWeitzYLifshitzZ, 1948, “Report on a settlement of the Arab refugee issue”, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2445-htz/3 (in Hebrew).
DeanM, 2002, “The development and implementation of Nazi denaturalization and confiscation policy up to the Eleventh Decree to the Reich Citizenship Law”Holocaust and Genocide Studies16(2) 217–242.
24.
DelaneyD, 1993, “Geographies of judgment: The doctrine of changed conditions and the geopolitics of race”Annals of the Association of American Geographers8348–65.
25.
DelaneyD, 1998Race, Place and the Law: 1836–1948University of Texas Press, Austin, TX).
26.
DomkeM, 1943Trading with the Enemy in World War 2Central Books, New York).
27.
FischbachM, 2002, “The United Nations and Palestinian refugee property compensation”Journal of Palestine Studies31601–617.
28.
FischbachM, 2003Records of Dispossession: Palestinian Refugee Property and the Arab–Israeli ConflictColumbia University Press, New York).
29.
FordR, 2001, “Introduction—local racisms and the law”, in The Legal Geographies Reader Eds BlomelyNDelaneyDFordR (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 52–53.
30.
Foreign Ministry, 1949, Summary of 1 May Meeting of Ben-Gurion, Kaplan, Sharet, Shafrir and Lifshitz, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2401-htz/21 I (in Hebrew).
31.
Foreign Ministry, 1951a, “Summary of 27 August Meeting on the landed property of people in the country legally who are considered Absentees”, 2 September, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2401-htz/21 II (in Hebrew).
32.
Foreign Ministry, 1951b, Letter from the Committee on the property of ‘Absentees’ living legally in Israel to the Foreign Minister, 5 September, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2401-htz/21 II (in Hebrew).
33.
Foreign Ministry, 1952, Letter from the Committee on the property of ‘absentees’ living legally in Israel to the Foreign Minister, 8 January, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2402-htz/3 (in Hebrew).
34.
ForestB, 2000, “Placing the law in geography”Historical Geography285–12.
35.
FormanG, 2002, “Settlement of title in the Galilee: Dowson's colonial guiding principles”Israel Studies7(3) 61–83.
36.
FormanGKedarA, 2003, “Colonialism, colonization and land law in Mandate Palestine: The Zor al-Zarqa and Barrat Qisarya land disputes in historic perspective”Theoretical Inquiries in Law4(2) 491–539.
37.
GolanA, 1992, “The transfer of abandoned rural arab lands to Jews during Israel's War of Independence”Cathedra63122–154 (in Hebrew).
38.
GolanA, 1993Transformation of the Settlement Map in Regions Abandoned by the Arab Population as a Result of the War of Independence, in the Territory in which the State of Israel was Established (1948–50) unpublished PhD thesis, Department of Geography, Hebrew University, Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
39.
GolanA, 1995, “The transfer to Jewish control of abandoned Arab lands during the War of Independence”, in Israel: The First Decade of Independence Eds TroenS ILucasN (SUNY Press, Albany, NY) pp 403–440.
40.
GolanA, 2001Wartime Spatial Changes: Former Arab Territories Within the State of Israel, 1948–1950Ben-Gurion University Press, Beer-Sheva) (in Hebrew).
41.
Government of Palestine, 1945, “The Defense (Emergency) Regulations, 1945”Palestine Gazettenumber 1442, supplement 2, 27 September.
42.
Government of Palestine, 1991aA Survey of Palestine (Jerusalem)Institute of Palestine Studies, Washington, DC); first published in 1946.
43.
Government of Palestine, 1991bSupplement to Survey of Palestine (Jerusalem)Institute of Palestine Studies, Washington, DC); first published in 1947.
44.
GranottA, 1952Neteevot U Mefalseem 133–34 [Paths and pathbreakers] (Devir Publishing, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew).
45.
GranottA, 1956Agrarian Reform and the Record of IsraelEyre and Spottiswoode, London).
46.
HadawiS, 1988Palestinian Rights and Losses: A Comprehensive StudySaqi Books, London).
47.
HaleR, 1993, “Coercion and distribution in a supposedly non-coercive state”, in American Legal Realism Eds FisherWHorowitzMReedT (Oxford University Press, New York) pp 101–108; first published in 1923.
48.
HarrisonJHolderC, 2003Law and Geography: Current Legal Issues 2002volume 5 (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
49.
HofnungM, 1991Israel—Security Needs vs. the Rule of LawNevo, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew).
50.
HoltzmanY, 1999, “Land expropriation law in the 1950's and the Zionist ideology of immigrant absorption and private property”, in Land in Israel Ed. DaganH (University of Tel Aviv, Tel-Aviv) pp 223–252 (in Hebrew).
51.
ILA, 1965Report on the Operations of the Israel Lands Administration for the Year 1964–5Israel Lands Administration, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew).
52.
Interior Ministry, 1949–52, “Return of non-absentee property”, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (56) 2201-gim/29 (in Hebrew).
53.
JA, 1951Report on the Management of the Zionist Organization and the Management of the Jewish Agency for Israel: 23rd CongressJewish Agency for Israel, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew).
54.
JiryisS, 1976The Arabs in IsraelMonthly Review Press, London).
55.
JNF, 1951, Letter from a Jewish National Fund official to the Development Authority Chairman, Jewish National Fund, 23 August, Central Zionist Archives, Jerusalem, JNF5/18910 (in Hebrew).
56.
JNF, 1954, “A joint institution for national land in Israel (main points for a proposal)”, Jewish National Fund, 22 December, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (43) 5497-gim/2623 (in Hebrew).
57.
JNF, 1956, “Assumptions regarding the JNF's future”, Jewish National Fund, 30 March, Central Zionist Archives, Jerusalem, A202/192 (in Hebrew).
58.
KamenC, 1985, “After the disaster: The Arabs in Israel, 1948–1950”Mahbarot l'Mihkar u-l'Bikoret (in Hebrew).
59.
KanoJ, 1992The Problem of Land Between Jews and ArabsSifriat Poalim, Tel-Aviv) (in Hebrew).
60.
KarkR, 1995, “Planning, housing and land policy 1948–1952: The formation of concepts and governmental frameworks”, in Israel: The First Decade of Independence Eds TroenS ILucasN (SUNY Press, Albany, NY) pp 461–493.
61.
KatzY, 1992, “Transfer of population as a solution to international disputes: Population exchanges between Greece and Turkey as a model for plans to solve the Jewish–Arab dispute in Palestine during the 1930s”Political Geography1155–72.
62.
KatzY, 2000, “The land will not be sold: The principle of national land in the legislative process and Israeli law”Karka4846–79 (in Hebrew).
63.
KedarA (S), 1998, “Majority time, minority time: Land, nationality and adverse possession law in Israel” 'Iyunei Mishpat21665–746 (in Hebrew).
64.
KedarA (S), 2001, “The legal transformation of ethnic geography: Israeli law and the Palestinian landholder 1948–1967”New York University Journal of International Law and Politics33923–1000.
65.
KedarA (S), 2003, “On the legal geography of ethnocratic settler states: Notes towards a research agenda”, in Law and Geography: Current Legal Issues 2002volume 5, Eds HolderJHarrisonC (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 401–442.
66.
KimmerlingB, 1983Zionism and Territory: The Socio-territorial Dimensions of Zionist PoliticsInstitute of International Studies, Berkeley, CA).
67.
Knesset Economics Committee, 1950, “Minutes of proceedings”, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem, (60) 21-kaf/12 (in Hebrew).
68.
Knesset Law and Constitution Committee, 1949–50, “Minutes of the Absentee Property Law Sub-committee”, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (60) 27-kaf/6 (in Hebrew).
69.
KornDShapiraB, 1997Coalition Politics in IsraelZmora-Bitan, Tel-Aviv) (in Hebrew).
70.
KretzmerD, 1990The Legal Status of the Arabs in IsraelWestview Press, Boulder, CO).
71.
LALIC, 1954, “Minutes of the Land Acquisition Law Implementation Committee”, 1 April, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2402-htz/5 (in Hebrew).
72.
LehnWDavisU, 1988The Jewish National FundKegan Paul, London).
73.
LifshitzZ, 1949, “Report on the need for a legal settlement of the issue of Absentee Property”, 18 March, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2401/21 I (in Hebrew).
74.
LiskovskiA, 1959, “The present absentees in Israel”, Report of the Office of the Arab Affairs Advisor, August, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem, 348 PR 3/959/27 (in Hebrew).
75.
LustickI, 1980Arabs in the Jewish State: Israel's Control of a National MinorityUniversity of Texas Press, Austin, TX).
76.
MAPC, 1948a, “Minutes of the Ministerial Abandoned Property Committee”, 13 July, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2401/21I (in Hebrew).
77.
MAPC, 1948b, “Minutes of the Ministerial Abandoned Property Committee”, 26 July, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2401/21I (in Hebrew).
78.
MAPC, 1948c, “Minutes of the Ministerial Abandoned Property Committee”, 20 August, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2564-htz/13 (in Hebrew).
79.
MAPC, 1948d, “Minutes of the Ministerial Abandoned Property Committee”, 27 August, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2564-htz/13 (in Hebrew).
80.
MorrisB, 1987The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem, 1947–1949Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
81.
NakkaraH, 1985, “Israeli land seizure under various defense and emergency regulations”Journal of Palestine Studies14(2) 13–34.
82.
Oren-NordheimM, 2000The Evolution of Israeli Land and Settlement Policy from the Establishment of the State through the First Years of the Israel Lands Administration: 1948–1965 unpublished PhD thesis, Department of Geography, Hebrew University, Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
83.
PalmonY, 1952, Letter from Arab Affairs Advisor to Prime Minister, Foreign Minister, Finance Minister, Agriculture Minister, Israel Defense Forces Chief of Staff, and Attorney General, 28 January, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2402-htz/3 (in Hebrew).
84.
PeretzD, 1958Israel and the Palestine ArabsMiddle East Institute, Washington, DC).
85.
PoratM, Letter from the Custodian of Absentee Property to the Finance Minister (in Hebrew).
86.
PoratM, 1951a, 11 February, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2401-htz/21 II.
87.
PoratM, 1951b, 5 August, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2401-htz/21 II.
88.
PoratM, 1951c, 4 September, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2401-htz/21 II.
89.
RodedB, 2002, “Land regimes—comparative analysis: Sri-Lanka, Australia and Estonia”, in The Israeli Land Regime: Final Scientific Report for the Period 1999–2001 Eds KedarAYiftachelO (report submitted to the Israeli Science Foundation for Grant No. 761/99, copy available from Forman and Kedar).
90.
RubinsteinA, 1996Constitutional Law of the State of IsraelSchoken, Israel) (in Hebrew).
91.
SAPRC, 1951, “Procedure of the Special Absentee Property Release Committee”, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem (130) 2564-htz/13 (in Hebrew).
92.
SchechtmanJ, 1949Population Transfers in AsiaHallsby Press, New York).
93.
SchechtmanJ, 1962Postwar Population Transfers in Europe 1945–1955University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, PA).
94.
SchechtmanJ, 1964The Refugees in the World: Displacement and IntegrationBarnes, New York).
95.
SingerJ W, 1992, “Sovereignty and property”Northwestern University Law Review861.
96.
SLLC, 1955, “Minutes of the Supreme Land Leasing Committee”, 20 April 1955, Central Zionist Archives Jerusalem, JNF5/22254 (in Hebrew).
97.
SLLC, 1956, “Minutes of the Supreme Land Leasing Committee”, 15 February, Israel State Archives, Jerusalem, JNF5/23905 (in Hebrew).
98.
SojaE, 1996, “Symposium: Surveying law and borders, afterward”Stanford Law Review481421–1425.
99.
State of Israel. 1948a, “Abandoned Areas Ordinance”Official Gazettenumber 7, supplement 1, 30 June (in Hebrew).
100.
State of Israel. 1948b, “Fallow Lands Regulations”Official Gazettenumber 27, supplement 2, 15 October (in Hebrew).
101.
State of Israel. 1948c, “Absentee Property Regulations”Official Gazettenumber 37, supplement 2, 12 December (in Hebrew).
102.
State of Israel. 1949a, “The Absentee Property Regulations Extension of Force Bill”Billsnumber 22, 10 November (in Hebrew).
103.
State of Israel. 1949b, “Transfer of Property to the Development Authority Bill”Billsnumber 25, 8 December (in Hebrew).
104.
State of Israel. 1949cKnesset Proceedings 3 22 November (in Hebrew).
105.
State of Israel. 1949d3, Knesset Proceedings 3 23 November (in Hebrew).
106.
State of Israel. 1949eKnesset Proceedings 3 14 December (in Hebrew).
107.
State of Israel. 1949fKnesset Proceedings 3 5 December (in Hebrew).
108.
State of Israel. 1950a, “Absentee Property Law”Laws of the State of Israelnumber 37, 20 March (in Hebrew).
109.
State of Israel. 1950bKnesset Proceedings 4 27 February (in Hebrew).
110.
State of Israel. 1950c, “Development Authority (Transfer of Property) Law”Laws of the State of Israel, number 57, 9 August (in Hebrew).
111.
State of Israel. 1951, “The State Property Law”Laws of the State of Israelnumber 68, 15 February (in Hebrew).
112.
State of Israel. 1952a, “Land Acquisition (Validation of Acts and Compensation) Bill”Billsnumber 118, 26 May (in Hebrew).
113.
State of Israel. 1952bKnesset Proceedings 12 3 June (in Hebrew).
114.
State of Israel. 1953aKnesset Proceedings 13 4 March (in Hebrew).
115.
State of Israel. 1953bKnesset Proceedings 13 10 March (in Hebrew).
116.
State of Israel. 1953c, “Land Acquisition (Validation of Acts and Compensation) Law”Laws of the State of Israelnumber 122, 20 March (in Hebrew).
117.
State of Israel. 1959a, “Basic Law: The People's Lands”Billsnumber 388, 8 April (in Hebrew).
118.
State of Israel. 1959b, “The People's Lands Bill”Billsnumber 401, 13 July (in Hebrew).
119.
1959c, “The People's Lands Administration Bill”Billsnumber 402, 20 July (in Hebrew).
120.
State of Israel. 1959dKnesset Proceedings 27 3 August (in Hebrew).
121.
State of Israel. 1959eKnesset Proceedings 27 6 August (in Hebrew).
122.
State of Israel. 1960a, “Basic Law: Israel Lands”Laws of the State of Israelnumber 312, 29 July (in Hebrew).
123.
State of Israel. 1960b, “Israel Lands Law-1960”Laws of the State of Israelnumber 312, 29 July (in Hebrew).
124.
State of Israel. 1960c, “Israel Lands Administraiton Law”Laws of the State of Israelnumber 312, 29 July (in Hebrew).
125.
State of Israel. 1960dKnesset Proceedings 28 22 February (in Hebrew).
126.
State of Israel. 1968, “Covenant between the State of Israel and the JNF”Government Publications (Yilkut Hapirsumim) number 1456, 1597–1598.
127.
TsizlingA, 1948, Letter from Agriculture Minister to Histadrut Central Council, 26 July, Labor Movement Archives IV-235-1-2251C (in Hebrew).
128.
VaksA, 1949, “A comment on the new Absentee Property Regulations”Hapraklit628–29 (in Hebrew).
129.
VernantJ, 1953The Refugee in the Post-war WorldAllen and Unwin, London).
130.
WeismanY, 1993Land Law—General SectionFaculty of Law, Hebrew University, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew).
131.
WeitzY, 1954a, Letter entitled “Report on the country's land regime”, from Director of the JNF's Department of Lands to Finance Minister Levy Eshkol, 5 September, Central Zionist Archives, Jerusalem, KKL5/22273 (in Hebrew).
132.
WeitzY, 1954b, “Summary of operations to implement the Land Acquisition (Validation of Acts and Compensation) Law, 1953”, 12 April, Central Zionist Archives, Jerusalem A246/275 (in Hebrew).
133.
WeitzY, 1965My Journal and Letters for My SonsMasadeh, Ramat-Gan) (in Hebrew).
134.
YifrahS, 1949, “Legislation Concerning Property and Government in the Conquered Areas”Hapraklit18(6) 90–94 (in Hebrew).
135.
YiftachelOKedarA (S), 2000, “Landed power: The making of the Israeli land regime”Theory and Criticism1667–100 (in Hebrew).
