This paper provides a critique of the concept of the throwaway society. Drawing on two years of intensive qualitative research, we argue that the concept of the throwaway society does not bear scrutiny. Rather than throwing things away households are shown consistently to engage in simultaneous practices of saving and wasting when getting rid of consumer objects. Saving and wasting are shown to be critical to materialising identities and the key social relations of family and home. Focusing on self, the couple relation, and the mother–child relation, we show how wasting things is intimately connected to the narration of self and to the enactment of specific love relations. The paper also shows how wasting things is central to moving home, constituting a surplus and then an excess of household possessions. The paper concludes by arguing that to understand the increasing amount of matter being turned to waste in the UK requires a focus on love relations and mobility, and not on the trajectories of things themselves.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AppaduraiA, (Ed.), 1986The Social Life of Things: Commodities in Cultural Perspective (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
2.
AttfieldJ, 2000Wild Things: The Material Culture of Everyday Life (Berg, Oxford)
3.
BarrS, 2004, “What we buy, what we throw away and how we use our voice, sustainable household waste management in the UK”Sustainable Development1232–44
4.
BatailleG, 1989The Accursed Sharevolume 1 (Zone Books, New York)
5.
BelkR, 1995Collecting in a Consumer Society (Routledge, London)
6.
BuchliVLucasG, 2000, “Children, gender and the material culture of domestic abandonment in the late 20th century”, in Children and Material Culture Ed. Sofaer-DerevenskiJ, (Routledge, London) pp 131–138
7.
BuchliVLucasG, 2001Archaeologies of the Contemporary Past (Routledge, London)
8.
BulkeleyHAskinsKWatsonMHudsonRWeaverP, 2005Governing Waste Sustainably: Final ReportDepartment of Geography and Wolfson Research Institute, University of Durham
9.
ChappellsHShoveE, 1999, “The dustbin: A study of domestic waste, household practices and utility services”International Planning Studies4267–280
10.
ClarkeA, 2000, “Mother swapping: The trafficking of nearly new children's wear”, in Commercial Cultures: Economies, Practices, Spaces Eds JacksonPLoweMMillerDMortF, (Berg, Oxford) pp 85–100
11.
ClarkeAMillerD, 2002, “Fashion and anxiety”Fashion Theory6191–214
12.
Colloredo-MansfeldR, 2003, “Introduction: Matter unbound”Journal of Material Culture8245–254
13.
CooperT, 2003, “Durable consumption: Reflections on product life cycles and the throwaway society”, paper presented at Product Life and the Throwaway Society workshop, Centre for Sustainable Consumption, Sheffield Hallam University, 21 May
14.
CooperT, 2005, “Slower consumption: Reflections on product lifespan and the throwaway society”Journal of Industrial Ecology951–67
15.
CooperTMayersK, 2000Prospects for Household Appliances: The E-scope ReportUrban Mines Ltd, The Cobbelt Centre, Village Street, Norwood Green, Halifax HX3 8QG
16.
CwernerSMetcalfeA, 2003, “Storage and clutter: Discourses and practices of order in the domestic world”Journal of Design History16229–239
17.
DantT, 1999Material Culture in the Social World: Values, Activities, Lifestyles (Open University Press, Buckingham)
18.
DouglasM, 1966Purity and Danger: An Analysis of the Concepts of Pollution and Taboo (Routhdege, London)
19.
FinchJ, 1989Family Obligations and Social Change (Polity Press, Cambridge)
20.
FinchJMasonJ, 1990, “Divorce, re-marriage and family obligations”Sociological Review38219–246
21.
FisherTShiptonJ, 2003, “In and out of the twilight zone: Understanding packaging re-use”, paper presented at Product Life and the Throwaway Society Workshop, Centre for Sustainable Consumption, Sheffield Hallam University, 21 May
HallamEHockeyJ, 2001Death, Memory and Material Culture (Berg, Oxford)
25.
HawkinsGMueckeS, (Eds), 2003Culture and Waste: The Creation and Destruction of Value (Rowman and Littlefield, Lanham, MD)
26.
HertzR, 1960Death and the Right Hand (Free Press, New York)
27.
HetheringtonK, 2004, “Secondhandedness: Consumption, disposal, and absent presence”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space22157–173
28.
HuyssenA, 1995Twilight Memories: Making Time in a Culture of Amnesia (Routledge, London)
29.
KopytoffI, 1986, “The cultural biography of things: Commodification as a process”, in The Social Life of Things Ed. AppaduraiA, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 64–94
30.
KwintMBrewardCAynsleyJ, (Eds), 1999Material Memories: Design and Evocation (Berg, Oxford)
31.
LayneL, 1999, “He was a real baby with baby things: A material culture of personhood, parenthood and pregnancy loss”Journal of Material Culture5321–345
32.
LowenthalD, 1990The Past is a Foreign Country (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
33.
LucasG, 2002, “Disposability and dispossession in the twentieth century”Journal of Material Culturel5–22
34.
McCrackenG, 1988Culture and Consumption (Indiana University Press, Bloomington, IN)
35.
MacdonaldS, 2002Behind the Scenes at the Science Museum (Berg, Oxford)
MillerDJacksonPThriftNHolbrookBRowlandsM, 1998Shopping, Place and Identity (Routledge, London)
44.
MunroR, 1995, “Disposal of the meal”, in Food Choice and the Food Consumer Ed. MarshallD, (Blackie, Glasgow) pp 313–325
45.
NorrisL, 2004, “Shedding skins: The materiality of divestment in India”Journal of Material Culture959–71
46.
O'BrienM, 1999, “Rubbish power: Towards a sociology of the rubbish society”, in Consuming Cultures Eds HearnJRoseneilS, (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 262–277
WardeA, 2005, “Consumption and theories of practice”Journal of Consumer Culture5131–153
60.
WoodwardS, 2005, “Looking good: Feeling right—aesthetics of the self”, in Clothing as Material Culture Eds KüchlerSMillerD, (Berg, Oxford) pp 21–40
61.
WrightP, 1985On Living in an Old Country (Verso, London)
62.
YoungD, 2001, “The life and death of cars: Private vehicles on the Pitjantjatjara Lands, South Australia”, in Car Cultures Ed. MillerD, (Berg, Oxford) pp 35–57
