In this paper we offer a critical analysis of ethnic relations in an Israeli ‘mixed city’. Similar to other sites shaped by the logics of settling ethnonationalism and capitalism, the ‘mixed city’ is characterized by stark patterns of segregation between a dominant majority and a subordinate minority, as well as by ethnoclass fragmentation within each group. ‘Mixed’ spaces are both exceptional and involuntary, often resulting from the process of ethnicization prevalent in contested urban spaces. We theorize this setting as an ‘urban ethnocracy’, where a dominant group appropriates the city apparatus to buttress its domination and expansion. In such settings, conspicuous tensions accompany the interaction between the city's economic and ethnoterritorial logics, producing sites of conflict and instability, and essentializing group identities and ethnic geographies. Empirically, the paper focuses on the city of Lod or Lydda, Israel, where the production of contested urban space has been linked to the construction of an exclusionary Israeli-Jewish national identity and to the establishment of hierarchical ethnic citizenship. Like other previously Arab cities, Lod has been the target of a concerted strategy of Judaization, which has formed the city's central planning goal since the late 1940s. We analyze in detail various aspects and sites of the Judaization process, and of the ensuing urban conflicts. We point to the chronic instability of urban ethnocracies, and to the need of planning to rise above narrow ethnocentric considerations in order for the ‘mixed city’ to prosper as the home for all communities.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adalah, 1998Legal Violation of Arab Minority Rights in IsraelAdalah—The Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel, PO Box 510, Shfaram 20200, Israel.
2.
AlSayyadN, 1996, “Culture, identity and urbanism in a changing world: A historical perspective on colonialism, nationalism and globalisation”, in Preparing for the Urban Future: Global Pressures and Local Forces Eds CohenMRubleBTulchinJGarlandA, (Woodrow Wilson Center Press, Baltimore, MD) pp 106–133.
3.
AndersonB, 1983Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism 2nd edition (Verso, London).
4.
BashirN, 1999The Palestinian Inhabitants in the Mixed Cities—Demography, Education Employment and Crime. The Center of Alternative Information, Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
5.
BenvenistiM, 1996City of Stone: The Hidden History of Jerusalem (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).
6.
BenvenistiM, 2001Sacred Landscape (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).
7.
BenzimanUMansourA, 1992Subtenants (Keter, Jerusalem) (in Hebrew).
8.
BilligM, 1995Banal Nationalism (Sage, London).
9.
BisharaA, 1993, “On the question of the Palestinian minority in Israel”, in Theory and Critique number 3, Van Leer Institute, Jerusalem, pp 7 – 35 (in Hebrew).
10.
BoalF, 1987, “Segregation”, in Progress in Social Geography Ed. PacioneM, (Croom Helm, London) pp 90 – 128.
11.
BollensS, 1999Urban Peace-building in Divided Societies (Westview Press, Boulder, CO).
12.
BrubakerR, 1996Nationalism Reframed: Nationhood and the National Question in the New Europe (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
13.
CanovanM, 1996Nationhood and Political Theory (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos).
14.
CastellsM, 1983The City and the Grassroots: A Cross-cultural Theory of Urban Social Movement (Arnold, London).
15.
CastellsM, 1996The Rise of the Network Society (Blackwell, Oxford).
16.
CastellsM, 1997The Power of Identity: Economy, Society and Culture (Blackwell, Oxford).
17.
Central Bureau of Statistics, 1995Census of Population and Housing. Central Bureau of Statistics, Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
18.
Central Bureau of Statistics, 1999Statistical Abstract of Israel number 50, Central Bureau of Statistics, Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
19.
ChatterjeeP, 1996, “Whose imagined community?”, in Mapping the Nation Ed. BalakrishnanG, (Verso, London) pp 73 – 98.
20.
City of Akko, 1988A New Future for Akko?City of Akko, Akko; copy available in Lod Municipality Archive, Lod (in Hebrew).
21.
City of Lod, 1952Lod—Three Years of Municipal RegimeCity of Lod, Lod; copy available in Lod Municipality Archive, Lod (in Hebrew).
22.
City of Lod, 2000Lod Municipality ReportCity of Lod, Lod (in Hebrew), copy available from Haim Yacobi.
23.
CohenH, 2000The Present Absentees: The Palestinian Refugees in Israel Since 1948. The Institute for Israeli Arab Studies, Van Leer Institute, Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
24.
ComaroffJ, 1998, “Reflections on the colonial state in South Africa and elsewhere: Factions, fragments and fictions”Social Identities4321 – 361.
25.
ComaroffJComaroffJ, 2000, “Naturing the nation: Aliens, apocalypse and the postcolonial state”Hagar: International Social Science Review1(1) 321 – 361.
26.
ConnorW, 1994Ethnonationalism: The Quest for Understanding (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ).
27.
DahlR A, 1982Dilemmas of Pluralist Democracy: Autonomy Versus Control (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT).
28.
DumperM, 1996The Politics of Jerusalem Since1967 (University of Columbia Press, New York).
FalahG, 1996, “Living together apart: Residential segregation in mixed Arab – Jewish cities in Israel”Urban Studies33823 – 857.
31.
FensterT, 2002, “Planning as control—cultural and gendered manipulation and mis-use of knowledge”Hagar: International Social Science Review3(2) 98 – 114.
32.
FernandesEVarleyA, 1998, “Law, the city and citizenship in developing countries: An introduction”, in Illegal Cities: Law and Urban Change in Developing Countries Eds FernandesDVarleyA, (Zed Books, London) pp 3 – 17.
33.
FincherRJacobsJ, (Eds) 1998Cities of Difference (Guilford Press, New York).
34.
FoucaultM, 1977, “Panopticism”, in Discipline and Punish translated by SheridanA, (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx) pp 356 – 366.
35.
FriedmannJ, 1996Two Centuries of Planning Theory: An Overview. Explorations in Planning Theory Eds MandelbaumSMazzaLBurchellR, (Center for Urban Policy Research, New Brunswick, NJ) pp 10 – 30.
36.
GellnerE, 1983Nations and Nationalism (Blackwell, Oxford).
37.
GolanA, 2001Spatial Change—The Result of War: Ex-Arab Areas in the State of Israel, 1948 –1950 (Ben-Gurion University Press, Beer-Sheva).
38.
GreenfeldL, 1992Nationalism: Five Roads to Modernity (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA).
39.
GurrT RKingD S, 1987The State and the City (Macmillan, London).
40.
HallP, 1988Cities of Tomorrow: An Intellectual History of Urban and Regional Planning (Blackwell, Oxford).
41.
HashimshoniZ, 1969Lod—The Old City Census. The Evacuation and Construction Authority, Ministry of Housing and Construction, Government City, Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
42.
HeldD, 1990Models of Democracy (Polity Press, London).
43.
HollidayC, 1933, “Candidates statement”, May 1933, Royal Institute of British Architects Archive, 66 Portland Place, London, W1B 1AD.
44.
JacksonPPenroseJ, (Eds) 1993Constructions of Race, Place and Nation (UCL Press, London).
45.
JacobsJ M, 1996The Edge of Empire: Postcolonialism and the City (Routledge, London).
46.
KadishASelaAGolanA, 2000The Occupation of Lydda, July 1948. Ministry of Defense, Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
47.
KallusRLaw-YoneH, 2000, “National home/personal home: The role of public housing in the shaping of space”Theory and Critique number 16, Van Leer Institute, Jerusalem, pp 153 – 180.
48.
KatznelsonI, 1995, “Social justice, liberalism and the city”, in The Urbanization of Injustice Eds MorrifieldASwyngedouwE, (Lawrence and Wishart, London) pp 45 – 64.
49.
KedarS, 1998, “Majority time, minority time: Land, nation and the law of adverse possession in Israel”Iyyuney Mishpat21(3) 665 – 746 (in Hebrew).
50.
KimmerlingB, 2001The Invention and Decline of Israeliness (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).
51.
KymlickaW, 1995Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights (Clarendon Press, Oxford).
LefebvreH, 1996Writings on Cities (Blackwell, London).
54.
LindblomC E, 1977Politics and Markets (Basic Books, New York).
55.
LittleD, 1994Sri Lanka: The Invention of Enmity. US Institute for Peace, Washington, DC.
56.
LustickI, 1993Unsettled States, Disputed Lands (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY).
57.
LustickI, 1999, “Israel as a non-Arab state: The political implications of mass immigration of non-Jews”Middle East Journal53(3) 417 – 433.
58.
McGarryJ, 1998, “Demographic engineering: The state-directed movement of ethnic groups as a technique of conflict regulation”Ethnic and Racial Studies21(4) 613 – 638.
59.
MannM, 2000, “Democracy and ethnic war”Hagar: International Social Science Review1(2) 115 – 134.
60.
MarcuseP, 1995, “Not chaos, but walls: Postmodernism and the partitioned city”, in Postmodern Cities and Space Eds WatsonSGibsonK, (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 187 – 198.
61.
MarcusePvan KempenM, (Eds) 2000Globalising Cities: A New Spatial Order? (Blackwell, Oxford).
62.
Master Plan of Lod, 1997Inventory Report unpublished draft; copy available at Lod Municipality Archive, Lod (in Hebrew).
63.
MorrisB, 2000Righteous Victims (Alfred Knopf, New York).
64.
National Planning Team (headed by Ariel Sharon), 1952Physical Plan for Israel. Prime Minister's Office, Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
65.
PenroseJ, 2000, “The limitation of nationalist democracy: The treatment of marginal groups as a measure of state legitimacy”Hagar: International Social Science Review1(2) 33 – 62.
66.
SaidE, 1993The Culture of Imperialism (University of Columbia Press, New York).
67.
SandercockL, 1998Toward Cosmopolis: Planning for Multicultural Cities and Regions (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex).
68.
SassenS, 1994Cities in a World Economy (Pine Forge Press, Thousand Oaks, CA).
69.
SassenS, 1998Globalisation and its Discontents (John Wiley, New York).
70.
ShafirG, 1995Immigrants and Nationalists: Ethnic Conflict and Accommodation in Catalonia, the Basque Country, Latvia and Estonia (SUNY Press, Albany, NY).
71.
ShafirG, 1998, “Introduction: The evolving tradition of citizenship”, in The Citizenship Debate—A Reader Ed. ShafirG, (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, MN) pp 1 – 26.
72.
SibleyD, 1996Geographies of Exclusion—Society and Difference in the West (Routledge, London).
73.
Sikkuy, 2000, “Report on equality and integration of the Arab citizens in Israel”, Sikkuy, Jerusalem (in Hebrew).
74.
SmithD, (Ed.), 1991Apartheid City and Beyond (Routledge, London).
75.
StasiulisDYuval-DavisN, 1995, “Introduction: Beyond dichotomies—gender, race, ethnicity and class in settler societies”, in Unsettling Settler Societies Eds StasiulisDYuval-DavisN, (Sage, London) pp 1 – 26.
76.
TaylorP J, 2000, “World cities and territorial states under conditions of contemporary globalisation”Political Geography195 – 32.
77.
TzfadiaE, 2000, “Immigrants dispersal in settler societies: Mizrahim and Russians in Israel under press of hegemony”, in Geography Research Forum, Volume20 (Ben-Gurion University, Beer-Sheva) pp 52 – 69.
78.
VacartE, 1977Lod—A Geographical History. (Chericover, Lod) (in Hebrew).
79.
YacobiH, 2002, “From urban panopticism to spatial protest: Housing policy, segregation and social exclusion of the Palestinian community in Lydda – Lod”, in Middle East Report number 223, available at http://www.merip.org.
80.
YacobiH, 2003Urban Ethnocracy: The Construction of a City and Identities PhD thesis, Ben-Gurion University, Beer-Sheva.
81.
YiftachelO, 1996, “The internal frontier: The territorial control of ethnic minorities”Regional Studies30493 – 508.
82.
YiftachelO, 1997, “Israeli society and Jewish – Palestinian reconciliation: ‘ethnocracy’ and its territorial contradictions”Middle East Journal51505 – 519.
83.
YiftachelO, 1999, “‘Ethnocracy’: The politics of Judaizing Israel/Palestine”Constellations6364 – 391.
84.
YiftachelOKedarS, 2000, “Landed power: The making of the Israeli land regime”, in Theory and Critique number 16, Van Leer Institute, Jerusalem, pp 67 – 100 (in Hebrew).
85.
YoungI M, 1997Intersecting Voices: Dilemmas of Gender, Political Philosophy and Policy (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ).
86.
Yuval-DavisN, 2000, “Multi-layered citizenship and the boundaries of the ‘nation-state’”Hagar: International Social Science Review1(1) 112 – 127.
