This paper examines the construction of femininity within Russian women's prisons. On the basis of fieldwork carried out in three women's prisons in the secure and restricted penal zone within Mordovia, Russian Federation, we present unique and original qualitative data, as well as a critical engagement with contemporary Russian press sources. Starting from the assumption that the (free) female body is a particular target of Foucauldian disciplinary power, in that gender is a discipline which produces bodies and identities and operates as an effective form of social control, we examine the ways in which this disciplinary power of gender is compounded by bodily imprisonment. Criminal women are often considered not only to have broken the law but also to have offended against their culturally specific gender role expectations, and punishment applied to women prisoners is grounded not on what women are like, but on how women ‘ought’ to behave in a particular cultural context, with interventions coercing or persuading women to reintegrate into a recognisably ‘feminine’ form. We uncover Russia's exceptional and exclusionary geography of women's imprisonment, and rehabilitative and educational processes, including a beauty pageant, which seek to rescript criminal women toward a predetermined ‘ideal’ of Russian womanhood, and also explore the ways in which women seek to resist.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Afanas'evIu NKozlovV P, (Eds), 2004 – 05Istoriia stalinskogo Gulaga: Konets 1920kh – pervaia polovina 1950kh godov. Sobranie dokumentov [History of the Stalinist Gulag: The end of the 1920s to the first half of the 1950s. A collection of documents], 7 volumes (Rosspen, Moscow)
2.
Al'pernL, 2001Zhenshchiny i deti v rossiiskoi tyurmy: Zametki posetitelei tyurme [Women and children in Russian prisons: Notes of prison visitors] (Moscow Centre for Prison Reform, Moscow)
3.
Al'pernL, 2004Son i yav zhenskoi tyurmy [Dream and reality in women's prisons] (Aleteiya, St Petersburg)
4.
AshwinS, 2002, “‘A woman is everything’: The reproduction of Soviet ideals of womanhood in post-communist Russia”, in Work, Employment and Transition: Restructuring Livelihoods in Postcommunist Eastern Europe Eds SmithARainnieASwainA, (Routledge, London) pp 19–41
5.
BartkyS L, 1988, “Foucault, femininity, and the modernization of patriarchal power”, in Feminism and Foucault: Reflections on Resistance Eds DiamondIQuinbyL, (Northeastern University Press, Boston, MA) pp 61–86
6.
BosworthM, 1999Engendering Resistance: Agency and Power in Women's Prisons (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants)
7.
BuckleyM, 1992Perestroika and Soviet Women (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
8.
CarlenP, 1983Women's Imprisonment: A Study in Social Control (Routledge, London)
9.
CarlenP, 2002, “Introduction: Women and punishment”, in Women and Punishment: The Struggle for Justice Ed. CarlenP, (Willan, Cullompton, Devon) pp 3–20
10.
Chesney-LindM, 1997The Female Offender: Girls, Women and Crime (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA)
11.
Chesney-LindMEliasonM, 2006, “From invisible to incorrigible: The demonization of marginalized women and girls”Crime, Media, Culture2(1) 29–47
DalyK, 1994Gender, Crime and Punishment (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT)
14.
DirsuweitT, 1999, “Carceral spaces in South Africa: A case study of institutional power, sexuality and transgression in a women's prison”Geoforum3071–83
15.
FlynnE E, 2003, “Social control explanations of crime”, in Encyclopedia of Women and Crime Ed. RafterN Hahn (Checkmark, New York) pp 244–249
16.
FoucaultM, 1998The History of Sexuality, Volume 1: The Will to Knowledge (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx)
17.
GheithJ M, 2007, “‘I never talked’: Enforced silence, non-narrative memory, and the Gulag”Mortality12159–175
18.
GiallombardoR, 1966, “Social roles in a prison for women”Social Problems13268–288
19.
HughesD, 2000, “The ‘Natasha’ trade: The transnational shadow market of trafficking in women”Journal of International Affairs53625–651
20.
IrwinJCresseyD R, 1962, “Thieves, convicts and the inmate culture”Social Problems10142–155
21.
IsraelM, 2004, “Strictly confidential? Integrity and the disclosure of criminological and socio-legal research”British Journal of Criminology44715–740
22.
Kharakteristika osuzhdennykh k lisheniyu svobody. Po Materialam spetsial'noi perepisi [The characteristics of prisoners: Materials of a special census], 2001, volume 1 (Moscow).
23.
KingA, 2004, “The prisoner of gender: Foucault and the disciplining of the female body”International Journal of Women's Studies529–39
24.
KingR D, 1994, “Russian prisons after perestroika: End of Gulag?”British Journal of Criminology3462–81
25.
KingRWincupE, (Eds), 2007Doing Research on Crime and Prisons2nd edition (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
26.
KuntsmanA, forthcoming, “With a shade of disgust: Affective politics of sexuality and class in memoirs of the Stalinist Gulag”Slavic Review
27.
LapidusGW, 1978Women in Soviet Society: Equality, Development and Social Change (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
28.
LaurieNDwyerCHollowaySSmithF, 1999Geographies of New Femininities (Longman, Harlow, Essex)
29.
MallochM S, 1999, “Drug use, prison and the social construction of femininity”Women's Studies International Forum22349–358
30.
MikhlinS MKingR D, 1998, “The Russian prison system: Past, present and future”, in Prisons 2000 Eds MatthewsR RFrancisP, (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 219–239
31.
MillerS L, 1998Crime Control and Women (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA)
32.
MoranD, 2004, “Exile in the Soviet forest: ‘special settlers’ in northern Perm' Oblast”Journal of Historical Geography30395–413
33.
Moscow Helsinki Group, 2005Human Rights in Russian Regions 2004 (Moscow Helsinki Group, Moscow)Council of Europe.
34.
OleinikA, 2001, “La réforme administrative, élément clé de la réforme pénitentiaire dans les Républiques post-soviétiques”Revue française d'administration publiquenumber 99, 513–522
35.
OleinikA, 2007, “Le système pénitentiaire en Russie”, in Les systèmes pénitentiaires dans le monde Eds CéréJ-PJapiassuC E A, (Dalloz, Paris) pp 295–320
36.
OwenB, 1998‘In the Mix’: Struggle and Survival in a Women's Prison (SUNY Press, New York)
37.
PallotJ, 2005, “Russia's penal peripheries: Space, place and penalty in Soviet and post-Soviet Russia”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series3098–112
38.
PallotJ, 2007, “‘Gde muzh, tam zhena’ (where the husband is, so is the wife): Space and gender in post-Soviet patterns of penality”Environment and Planning A39570–589
39.
PallotJ, 2008, “Continuities in penal Russia: Space and gender in post-Soviet geography of punishment”, in What is Soviet Now? Identities, Legacies, Memories Eds LahusenTSolomanP HJr, (LIT Verlag, Berlin) pp 235–254
40.
PallotJMoranDPiacentiniL, forthcoming, “Remembering the past to secure the future: Patriotic discourses in Russia's penal peripheries”Europe – Asia Studies
41.
PiacentiniL, 2004aSurviving Russian Prisons: Punishment, Politics and Economy in Transition (Willan, Cullompton, Devon)
42.
PiacentiniL, 2004b, “Penal identities in Russian prison colonies”Punishment and Society6131–147
43.
PiacentiniLPallotJMoranD, forthcoming, “Creating ‘malaya rodina’ (little homeland): Transportation, gender and penal order in a Russian prison”Social and Legal Studies
44.
PriceR R, 1977, “The forgotten female offender”Crime and Delinquency23(2) 101–108
45.
PushkarevaL M, 1992, “The women in the ancient Russian family (tenth to fifteenth centuries)”, in Russian Traditional Culture: Religion, Gender, and Customary Law Ed. BalzerM Mandelstam (M E Sharpe, Armonk, NY) pp 105–121
46.
RobertsLIndermaurD, 2003, “Signed consent forms in criminological research: Protection for researchers and ethics committees but a threat to research participants?”Psychiatry, Psychology and Law10289–299
47.
SmykalinA S, 1998, “Pitanie v lageryakh i tyurmakh Sovietskoi Rossii: Istoricheskii aspekt” [Nutrition in camps and prisons in Soviet Russia: Historical aspect]Pravovedenie480–89
48.
TongR, 1984Women, Sex and the Law (Rowman and Littlefield, Totowa, NJ)
