This paper deals with second-generation Barbadians or ‘Bajan-Brits’, who have decided to ‘return’ to the birthplace of their parents, focusing on their reactions to matters relating to race relations and racialised identities. The importance of race and the operation of the ‘colour-class’ system in the Caribbean are established at the outset. Based on fifty-two qualitative in-depth interviews, the paper initially considers the positive things that the second-generation migrants report about living in a majority black country and the salience of such racial affirmation as part of their migration process. The paper then presents an analysis of the narratives provided by the Bajan-Brits concerning their reactions to issues relating to race relations in Barbadian society. The impressions of the young returnees provide clear commentaries on what are regarded as (i) the ‘acceptance of white hegemony’ within Barbadian society, (ii) the occurrence of de facto ‘racial segregation’, (iii) perceptions of the ‘existence of apartheid’, and (iv) ‘the continuation of slavery’. The account then turns to the contemporary operation of the colour-class system. It is concluded that, despite academic arguments that the colour-class dimension has to be put to one side as the principal dimension of social stratification in the contemporary Caribbean, the second-generation migrants are acutely aware of the continued existence and salience of such gradations within society. Thus, the analysis not only serves to emphasise the continued importance of racial-based stratification in the contemporary Caribbean, but also speaks of the ‘hybrid’ and ‘in-between’ racialised identities of the second-generation migrants.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AhmedS, 2000Strange Encounters: Embodied Others in Post-coloniality (Routledge, London)
2.
AndersonM LCollinsP H, (Eds), 2004Race, Class and Gender: An Anthology5th edition (Wadsworth, Belmont, CA)
3.
BackLSolomosJ, (Eds), 2000Theories of Race and Racism: A Reader (Routledge, London)
4.
BaronovDYelvingtonK A, 2003, “Ethnicity, race, class and nationality”, in Understanding the Contemporary Caribbean (Lynne Rienner, Boulder, CO.; Ian Randle, Kingston, West Indies) pp 209–238
5.
BecklesH, 1996, “Independence and the social crisis of nationalism in Barbados”, in Caribbean Freedom: Economy and Society from Emancipation to Present Eds BecklesHShepherdV, (Marcus Weiners, Princeton, NJ) pp 528–539
6.
BhabhaH, 1994The Location of Culture (Routledge, London)
7.
BonnettA, 2000White Identities: Historical and International Perspectives (Prentice Hall, Harlow, Essex)
8.
BrahA, 1994, “‘Race’ and ‘culture’ in the gendering of labour markets”, in The Dynamics of Race and Gender: Some Feminist Interventions Eds AfsharAMaynardM, (Taylor and Francis, London) pp 151–171
9.
BuenoL, 1997, “Dominican women's experiences of return migration: The life stories of five women”, in Caribbean Circuits: New Directions in the Study of Caribbean Migration Ed. PessarP, (Centre for Migration Studies, New York) pp 14–60
10.
ChamberlainM, 1995, “Family narratives and migration dynamics: Barbadians in Britain”Nieuwe West Indische Gids69253–275
11.
ChamberlainM, 1997Narratives of Exile and Return (St Martin's Press, New York)
12.
ChamberlainM, 2001, “Migration, the Caribbean and the family”, in Caribbean Families in Britain and the Transatlantic World Eds GoulbourneHChamberlainM, (Macmillan, London) pp 32–47
13.
ClarkeC, 1985, “Pluralism and plural societies: Caribbean perspectives”, in Geography and Ethnic Pluralism Eds ClarkeCLeyDPeachC, (Allen and Unwin, Sydney) chapter 2
14.
ClarkeC, 1986, “Sovereignty, dependency and social change in the Caribbean”, in South America, Central America and the Caribbean (Europa Publications, London) pp 20–25
15.
ConwayDPotterR B, 2007, “Caribbean transnational return migrants as agents of change”Geography Compass125–45
16.
CrossM, 1979Urbanisation and Urban Growth in the Caribbean (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
17.
DannGPotterR B, 1990, “Yellow man in the Yellow Pages: Sex and race typing in the Barbados telephone directory”Bulletin of Eastern Caribbean Affairs151–15
18.
de AlbuquerqueKMcElroyJ, 1999, “Race, ethnicity and social stratification in three Windward Islands”Journal of Eastern Caribbean Studies241–28
19.
FanonF, 1967Black Skin, White Mask translated by MarkmanC L, (Grove Press, New York)
20.
GilroyP, 1993The Black Atlantic: Modernity and Double Consciousness (Verso, London)
21.
GoudgeP, 2003The Power of Whiteness: Racism in Third World Development and Aid (Lawrence and Wishart, London)
GoulbourneHChamberlainM, 2001Caribbean Families in Britain and the Trans-Atlantic World (Macmillan, London)
24.
GramsciA, 1980Selections from the Prison Notebooks (International Publishers, New York)
25.
HallS, 1989, “New ethnicities”, in Critical Dialogues in Cultural Studies Eds MorleyDHuan-HsingC, (Routledge, London) pp 441–449
26.
JacksonP, 1989, “Geography, race, and racism”, in New Models in Geographyvolume 2, Eds PeetRThriftN, (Unwin Hyman, London) pp 176–195
27.
KarchC, 1982, “The growth of the corporate economy in Barbados: Class and race factors, 1980–1977”, in Contemporary Caribbean: A Sociological Reader Ed. CraigS, (College Press, Maracas, Trinidad)
28.
KarchC, 1985, “Class formation and class and race relations in the West Indies”, in The Middle Class in Dependent Countries Ed. JohnsonD C, (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA) pp 107–136
29.
LancasterR, 1991, “Skin colour, race and racism in Nicaragua”Ethnology30339–353
30.
LayneA, 1979, “Race, class and developments in Barbados”Caribbean Quarterly25120–135
31.
LewisL, 1990, “The politics of race in Barbados”Bulletin of Eastern Caribbean Studies1532–45
32.
LewisL, 2001, “The contestation of race in Barbadian society and the camouflage of conservatism”, in New Caribbean Thought: A Reader Eds MeeksBLindahlF, (University of the West Indies Press, Mona, Kingston) pp 144–195
LowenthalD, 1972West Indian Societies (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
35.
McLeodJ, 2000Beginning Postcolonialism (Manchester University Press, Manchester)
36.
MartinezE, 1998De Colores Means All of Us: Latina Views for a Multi-colored Century (South End Press, Cambridge, MA)
37.
MartinezE, 2004, “Seeing more than black and white”, in Race, Class and Gender Eds AndersonMCollinsP, (Thomson, Belmont, CA) pp 111–117
38.
PhillipsJPotterR B, 2005, “Incorporating race and gender into Caribbean return migration: The example of second-generation ‘Bajan-Brits’”, in The Experience of Return: Caribbean Perspectives Eds PotterRConwayDPhillipsJ, (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants) chapter 4
39.
PhillipsJPotterR B, 2006, “‘Black skins and white masks’: Post-colonial reflections on race, gender and second-generation return migration to the Caribbean”Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography27309–325
40.
PlazaD, 2002, “The socio-cultural adjustment of second generation British-Caribbean ‘return’ migrants to Barbados and Jamaica”Journal of Eastern Caribbean Studies27135–160
41.
PotterR B, 1993, “Urbanisation in the Caribbean and trends of global convergence–divergence”Geographical Journal80334–341
42.
PotterR B, 2001a, “Tales of two societies: A pilot study of foreign-born returning nationals to Barbados and St Lucia”, final report to the British Academy on Grant APN 29771, copy available from the author
43.
PotterR B, 2001b, “Narratives of socio-cultural adjustment among young return migrants to St Lucia and Barbados”Caribbean Geography1270–89
44.
PotterR B, 2001c, “‘Tales of two societies’: Young return migrants to St Lucia and Barbados”Caribbean Geography1224–43
45.
PotterR B, 2003a, “‘Foreign-born’ and ‘young’ returning nationals to Barbados: Results of a pilot study”, Reading Geographical paper 166, Reading University, Reading
46.
PotterR B, 2003b, “‘Foreign-born’ and ‘young’ returning nationals to St Lucia: Results of a pilot study”, Reading Geographical paper 168, Reading University, Reading
47.
PotterR B, 2005a, “‘Young, gifted and back’: Second-generation transnational return migrants to the Caribbean”Progress in Development Studies5213–236
48.
PotterR B, 2005b, “‘Citizens of descent’: Foreign-born and young returning nationals to St Lucia”Journal of Eastern Caribbean Studies301–30
49.
PotterR BDannG, 1986, “Dependent urbanization and retail change in Barbados, West Indies”, in Cities and Development in the Third World Eds PotterR BSalauA T, (Mansell, London) pp 172–197
PotterR BPhillipsJ, 2004, “The rejuvenation of tourism in Barbados 1993–2003: Reflections on the Butler model”Geography89240–247
52.
PotterR BPhillipsJ, 2006a, “Both black and symbolically white: The Bajan-Brit return migrant as post-colonial hybrid”Ethnic and Racial Studies29901–927
53.
PotterR BPhillipsJ, 2006b, “‘Mad dogs and transnational migrants?’ Bajan-Brit second-generation migrants and accusations of madness”Annals of the Association of American Geographers96586–600
